Further to the above post I have spent some extra time re-testing the HF filter with many of my 'Hi Res files' and whilst I can still hear the above mentioned affect in the dynamics noticeable in the lower mids, the filter is clearly having a positive almost analogue effect on Hi Res files also. I can hear why Rob included it. There is an SQ benefit and on reflection I could run with either 'on or off' for my Hi Res files, though still 'off' for Red Book.
I wonder if the filter is affecting dynamics through a draw on power (or perhaps processing?). Not that it matters why. I just wanted to post again because I didn't wish to unfairly criticise the benefits of the fiter with Hi Res files. (That was its specific design goal after all.)
It’s all variable dependent upon the music, the ears and the equipment I think. Same as with Crossfeed, there is no single universal setting that is ‘correct‘ right across the board. Then of course, there is the small issue of personal preference! You wouldn’t want it to be easy would you?
I have a Manley Absolute headphone amp which you can see in my ID photo. It allows for a lot of variation of things like the output impedance, amount of negative feedback, Push Pull or Single Ended tube operation, EQ in or out, SE or balanced headphone output for example. This allows for tuning the amp to your headphones which I have found makes a lot of difference and I have a better understanding now of why there can be such a variance in people’s reaction to different headphones, amps etc. I’ve come to realise that headphones are just as hard to get right as a speaker setup, maybe even harder in some respects. I have an old pair of HD800 which must be 10 years old now and had fallen into misuse, replaced by newer, ‘better’ models. Out of curiosity, I tried them with the Manley and on the balanced output, high impedance and tweaked to suit, they sound great.
One of the things that slightly irritates about forums is when people insist that theirs is the ‘correct’ position or the ‘best’ solution - there is no absolute best, just best suited to individual personal preference. And even, then, that preference can change based upon our mood and the particular music we are listening to. That’s the beauty and the frustration of it all.
I’m sorry. That’s all a bit philosophical for this early in the morning, I think I’m going stir crazy with Lockdown fever!