Ah too bad you didn't like them... seems to me like a faulty unit !
I use the utopia on my ha 6a with 1/4 cable and they sound great. With plenty of bass.
I also have a hifiman arya. And to my personal experience. The utopia sound more full bodied than the aryas !
Bass is even stronger. More impactful and very precise. Maybe a bit less extension below.
Treble is more refined. Midrange is less pronounced. Imaging and separation is on par with the arya.
Soundstage is taller and wider with the hifiman. Focals are more intimate. But stage is deeper.
Also the sound is more dynamic or punchier !
I have yet to try the new clear mg . Wich is to me the most sexy looking headphone !
Would love also to try the abyss 1266 and the high end kennerton's.
Nowadays I am rocking 12bh7 as input and 6l6gc for power. And this combination is very silent.
I think we all hear differently, and we all post our impressions here , wich are very personal !
Always listen for yourself when you can