[Bama91]

I want to replace my OEM iPhone 3Gs earbuds with higher quality earphones, but I still need to a remote/mic capability.  I really do not like the in-ear style earphones so the Yuin PK2 looks like what I need.
 
What remote/mic adapter would you recommend to go with the Yuin?
 
It seems like the Audio-Technica AT-MP100 and Shure MPA-3C are good options, but I have not found any direct comparison between the two.
 
Thanks

 

[a_recording]

Actually, the Monster iSonitalk (Yes that is a hideous name) seems like a better option than both of those, just because of the unusual design where you won't have 2 metres of cable coming out of your pocket. I have the Audio Techinca headset myself, and the mic is actually quite poor - when I did use it everyone would complain they couldn't hear me unless I lifted up the mic and actually spoke to it. I gave up on the whole headset thing and just unplug my earphones when I get a call.

 

[Bama91]

Hmmm... So, did you have better luck with the iSonitalk?  If either is better than the standard iPhone earbuds + remote/mic then it is a win for me.  I wonder if the Shure MPA-3C is any better.

 

[a_recording]

I don't actually have the iSonitalk. The design just seemed better to me because the mic/control part is separate from the headphone jack. Then again, having that big attachment stick out of your player is a risk too...

 

[dlbernau]

I have both. The Shure is much much better.Mic quality is good, as is durability. The at unit died after a few months but the mic quality was so poor I didnt bother replacing it.

 

[decyph3r]

Ok, I have just decided to get the ATH-M50, I'm now in search for a good Mic adapters. Shure MPA-3c vs. Monster iSoniTalk. Any suggestions? Reviews? Will these Mic adapters degrade the sound coming from the ATH-M50? I will mainly use this for my iPhone as I am always on the go, travelling from one place to another.