I understand that as well, but their have been excelent dubs. Samurai X: Trust and betrayal was great.Tomoe's voice actress was a little awkward at first, but the dub was great. Hiko Seijuro's opening lines in the ova have been forever etched in my mind: "
The moon stares down upon a diseased world" All the power of that opening remained in the deep voice of the Seijuro's actor.
I know most serious anime fans and older Gundam fans consider G Gundam to be a joke and hate Gundam Wing, but I felt their dubs were quite enjoyable. Dot Hack Sign's was also good. Vision of Escaflowne simply reused the cast of Gundam Wing for the most part so I won't go there; lets just say that I kept refering to Van as Trowa and Folken as Zeches till about halfway through the series
I liked the Gundam SEED dub, it wasn't the best but it was very coherent and consistent and I don't remember any characters that bothered me. Lucy's performance towards the end of Elfen Lied was beleivably haunting. As for Cowboy Bebop, i'm sure its name alone is all I need to mention. I just hope that if Fox goes through with it they don't actually make Keannu Reeves Spike. I respect the man but lates face it, his roles haven't exactly shown him to have a playful personality like Spike's.
I personally really enjoyed Eureka Seven, that dub was great. I'd go so far as to mark Erueka Seven as the end of a ten year era of good english dubs between roughly 1995-2005.
I couldn't stand the Haruhi Suzumiya dub, but then again I never expected to. It seems that the real problem is that any anime series heavy in Japanese cliches and ero just don't sound right in english at all. As much as I love anime, I guess I've never really been much of a fan of the path it was taking. I've really enjoyed plently of series with ero in them like Air Gear, Karin. Even Asu No Yoichi and Maria Holic to some extent. Kampfer was hilarilious. But the last few viewing seasons have been a bit much in my oppinion, I can't really say my subbed viewing list was that long this year. I'm tired of waiting for a little depth among an endless pile of fanservice.
Code Geass was great and I loved its concept, but I can't help but get the feeling that it could have been better if it took a more realistic art noir approach. I'm indifferent to the fact that it used air trek on mecha though
Originally Posted by
kn19h7 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
Really? I loved the hand drawn art style in shows like Dot Hack Sign, Gundam Wing, Vision of Escaflowne etc. If the artwork production is dirty like in G gundam thats a problem, but if its consistent and clean like in Gundam Wing/Escaflowne and other hand drawn works of the era I prefer it.
That said, I will admit that the detail level in Death Note amazed me. I'd like to say that I'm just not into this neon colors' trend but that would be a lie; I liked the crisp bright artwork in negima neo.
I guess the point for this rant is that while I prefer the older art, I like anime as a whole more than my own preferences and will continue to look out for ones I can enjoy; despite recent trends. To each his own I guess...
Originally Posted by
kn19h7 /img/forum/go_quote.gif