I used to use Amarra, but ended up switching to Roon a couple of years ago, which I really dig. While I'll never be able to fully recapture the days of my vinyl-buying youth -- when I'd go buy albums, bring them home, and listen to the albums while obsessing over liner notes -- Roon does give me back some of the more experiential aspects of those days. I also like its filtering, discovery, and how it integrates TIDAL into my collection as if the TIDAL catalog was on my media drives.
Great thoughts Jude. I'm with you on buying vinyl. I remember being a teenager and heading downtown to Sam the Record Man here in Toronto and then getting home and listening to Zeppelin IV and pouring over the huge liner notes. Kids today unfortunately won't get to share in that experience of spending hours in a record store and coming home with your found treasures.