Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBigCW /img/forum/go_quote.gif
If you know not of this rigorous experimentation, then you are just plain misinformed.
ABX Double Blind Tests: Interconnects and Wires
Secrets Feature Article
And many more I'm too tired to bring up. Somewhere in here someone posted an ABX test from a french forum where no difference was found between cheap sweaty interconnects and expensive AudioQuest ICs.
|
Yes, the concept of double blind testing is not unfamiliar to me after this much time in this hobby. I'm also familiar with various debates around the methodology regarding being tested in a strange environment, with an unfamiliar system and perhaps music you are not familiar with, under pressure of actually being tested.
Thanks for sharing the links, one of which I'd seen before. I'd hardly consider them earth shattering resources. I have read similar studies before with interest. The power cord results on the Secrets of HT site do not surprise me in the least and don't contradict what I've heard at times myself, but are of course very limited to the one system in that room with those people, many of which walked out and did not complete the test. Nevertheless, the results do not surprise me. On a side note, I've listened to JC-1 amps at length and have never found them very engaging (two different systems) - instead rather cool bordering on cold, and analytical.
You may also be familiar with a test one of the major rags (either Sterophile or TAS) did on speaker cables a few years ago. In it they tested a bunch of speaker cables of varying prices and construction, as well as a speaker cable made from very inexpensive HomeDepot house brand extension cord (12ga cord). Their results ranked the HomeDepot extension cord right up there with the better of the most expensive of the other options. I went out and tried it myself and it sounded pretty damn good in my system as well, though dealing with 12ga cord is not much fun, and it is butt ugly, unless you like safety orange and black as a color scheme. Again, none of this surprises me and I'd encourage you or anyone else to seek their own answers to these questions (well, it's pretty clear you already have all the answers you require, so I'll put that out there for others). For those curious enough there is
The Cable Company lending library. For a 5% non-refundable deposit you can try any interconnects or speaker cable in their extensive lending library. I have no connection to them whatsoever.
I've known for a very long time that music is important to me and brings great pleasure in my life. It was a very easy and, to use your language, a rational and logical step for me to investigate various options myself to see what works best for me, in my system, in my room, with my music, and to my ears. To accomplish this I choose to actually try these things myself. Why ever would I let a group of strangers in a hotel room with a system that doesn't bear much similarity to my own tell me what is good and what is not? Likewise I take comments by respected friends with a grain of salt, as they would my own, and reviews online and in the popular rags with the larger portion of a 5lb bag of salt.
Quote:
Originally Posted by TheBigCW
Lying to yourself is never a good thing, neither is the placebo effect because it is a delusion. You're convincing yourself to believe it sounds better when it doesn't. Cable manufacturers profit on making people lie to themselves, and that's completely awful.
|
Give me a break. So when the "placebo effect" actually works (lets just assume...or I will have to assume, and you can do your usual rigorous denial) that it is a "placebo effect" that cures the cancer in some drug study for instance (undeniably sometimes it works). Is that not a good thing? The mind has tremendous power that is most certainly capable of changing things about your body, your health, how you face the world and where you go in this life. It forms your entire path in life, with your help...it takes you all the places you've been and all those you are going to some degree. My experience has been when I shut it down and narrow my options, I will not get too far and life becomes very predictable and limited to a great degree. Whenever I open it up to possibilities, I get to places I would have never imagined were there. There is far more that we don't know, IMO, than those things we do know...or that we think we know. There is an entire universe out there that boggles the mind. If you can get past the dated music,
This short video presents a wonderful illustration of how small we are in relation to what we understand of what is out there (and in there).
Moreover, back on point, why would you want to deny someone else their own pleasure? What does that get you?
Quote:
Originally Posted by adrift
Respectfully, I'm not sure I get these arguments for subjectivity or self delusion. Ultimately they prove no real benefit and are easily manipulated for another's profit. Its one thing to argue the science (or argue against the science even), but its another thing altogether to shrug shoulders and say something like "I know its not real, but I don't mind pretending it is".
|
I am making no profit at having this discussion, nor will the results profit me at all. It is just stretching my mind while I have time during my recovery. I have absolutely nothing to benefit or nothing to loose here.
What is "real" and how an individual actually perceives it, can be two entirely different things. Isn't someone's personal pleasure "real" to them? Why would you want to spend your energies trying to deny that of anyone?