Pros: $10…TEN DOLLARS, inline mic, 14.8mm driver, smaller size bud
Cons: Thin cable, forward mids, trouble staying in my ears, $10…TEN DOLLARS
Introduction: The Head-Fi website is a place for many good things related to headphones, amplifiers, Digital Audio Players (DAPS), along with many more items. Manufacturers will often promote their new items on the site, and many of the experienced reviewers will get pre-production or first-run items. This is a good thing. A “trickle-down” effect of this is that other items from those same manufacturers will be opened up to “mini contests," lottery-type giveaways or a semi-interview process. This is also a good thing. While providing many more subscribers the opportunity to review their products, companies are smartly calling on people with a shared passion for quality music products.
Initial package, before opening
Back of package, complete with QR codes
With full foams-very good sound with these
It is through this route, that I was lucky enough to be chosen to review Fiio’s new EM-3 earbuds. Sunny, the Fiio contact was nothing but pleasant to work with via messaging, and a true professional who represents Fiio well. Providing quality customer/reviewer service is a good thing to have in a business that can be built further by word of mouth, or word of paper. It is beneficial in this regard, and just plain good business. I anxiously answered the required questions, put up onto the Head-Fi site another review so that Sunny could read my work, and waited. I was thankful, excited and honored to be chosen for this review product.
Disclaimer:
I have no affiliation with Fiio, other than the conversations related to the ordering of this review product, the EM-3. I do own several Fiio products ranging from the X3ii, to the A3, and E6 amps. I like them very much. My review will be an honest assessment of the EM-3, as I believe constructive criticism is as much a part of a good product review and will help the company not only address potential downsides of their product, but will also give the company an idea of the upsides of their product as well.
Biography:
I lost my Klipsch s4ii's....I was despondent. I had no good headphones as a result. Through a search of the Internet, I was led to Head-Fi, and my "reentry" into the personal-portable music world began. Through much reading and research, I was led first to the MEElectronic (now MEE Audio) m6 Pro's. I followed those with the excellent Dunu Titan 1's (excellent fresh sound). I then jumped on the VE Monk train (excellent little wonders they are!), followed by the intriguing RHA ma750's (which up until my review of the MEE Audio Pinnacle P1’s were my favorites, and are still quite good). After conversations with Sunny, the product was delivered via DHL…and I anxiously awaited their arrival.
Through no error of Fiio, I was unable to retrieve the EM’s on a Friday, as I was unaware (actually forgot…) that DHL would need to have a customer signature to finish delivery. I was highly disappointed, because I had the weekend planned for the review process. Oh well, I worked on another pair I am in the process of reviewing. In the mean time, I kept reading & researching, delving deeper into the Head-Fi world, leading to the findings which will be reviewed here and with the other phones in my possession...in due time...including the above mentioned product which I used over the weekend of wait.
I am no sound expert. I like good music, and appreciate excellent products as well as excellent valued products, such as the EM-3’s. My listening style varies from Stevie Ray Vaughan to Lyle Lovett, to Dave Matthews, to Bob Marley to Magic Slim & the Teardrops, to Coldplay, to Adele, and everything in between. As a result of too much loud rock and roll as a kid with $ and a car stereo of envy I now have hearing loss, mostly in the upper end. Anything sibilant or overly bright can and does bother me. That said, I am also a Wildlife Biologist/Earth Science teacher who studied songbirds in a different life...This allows me the ability to pick out a sound which should not be in that environment or is new to that environment...such as hearing a songbird on our surveys which had not been heard yet on our routes. I prided myself in that ability to pick out the sounds of what was not there upon our initial arrival. I like to think that this will help with my reviews, but I cannot guarantee it. I am post 50, but love good music and good sound quality. All opinions are mine and mine alone. I may reference others fine reviews, but only to draw a point of comparison. I do not own any sound testing equipment, nor am I a Sound Engineer. I am simply going off of my own interpretations and listenings. I do love going over the analytics of graphs and tone diagrams, etc, but my own seat-of-the-pants interpretations are what I have. YMMV.
Review
Packaging:
Almost shy, unassuming packaging greeted me when I opened the well packed ePacket from China. It was well protected. A simple black and white package with the ear buds prominently displayed on the front greets the new owner. Simple packaging matches the $10 price. Nothing fancy, just minimal packaging. I like it.
Simple black and white packaging, highlight the Fiio EM-3.
Opening the package you are met with a “smoked-glass” like cover over the wrapped cord and buds. Again, simple but I like it. One of the previous reviewers mentioned that this gave the Fiio’s a hidden upscale look. I cannot disagree.
Smoked cover adds allure!
The Em-3’s appeared well made, and after close inspection, they are very well made.
L-plug, a welcome part, which fits through Smartphone cases.
Full foam, again with thin cord, above "Y" splitter
Three sets of full foam covers are included.
Fiio’s motto: “Born For Music & Happy” a nice motto.
Technical Specs:
A large 14.8mm driver coupled with fairly high impedence (47ohms) and high sensitivity (109dB), mean that this pair is easy to drive with the average Smartphone. Volume was no trouble for the pair and my iPhone 6+. Wearing cargo pants or shorts, the cable is too short for me. Placed in regular pockets, I had no problem, though.
Interior of the bud, itself
Commentary:
Design/Build:
The EM-3 harkens back to a simpler time, when buds shaped like these were included in most early Smartphones. A Slight mimic of the old Apple earbuds, they do share a similar shape. That is the only similarity, thankfully. I would call then elegantly simple. Reinforced housing areas help where the cable comes out, and where the cable goes into the L-jack. Not overly huge, but well appreciated protection. As stated in my
CONS, the cables are thin, but they are strong. They tend to tangle more so than other buds I have owned, but with careful wrapping, this can be handled. I’m not sure how well this pair would handle being shoved in a pocket repeatedly, but if the “abuse” @Wiljen put his pair through (excellent review:
http://www.head-fi.org/products/fiio-em3-open-earbud-earphones-with-in-line-microphone-black/reviews/15696) in the washing machine and drier (they still worked!) is any indication, there should be no worries with the cable or connections.
For a $10 earbud, these are built very well. Fit and finish is top quality, something we have come to expect from pretty much all of our earphones, and these deliver. No loose seams, no mismatched screen covers, just evenly matched and well built.
Smaller sized bud, which fits my ear better
Features:
The only accessories included are three sets of foam covers. Nothing earth shattering, but quite stark in comparison to other similarly priced buds or IEM’s. At this price point, this is the norm. Again, no qualms from me.
Use:
The EM’s are meant for on-the-go use from mowing, to running, to listening in the evenings. My use will be of similar character, though I doubt I would use these for mowing or running…I simply cannot get ear buds to stayin my ears. Some might say Earhooks would solve this problem, but I am of the opinion, that if the purchased bud is inexpensive, it is almost a disservice to spend more money on them. The whole reason they are inexpensive is that the focus is on the sound, not the accessories. Many in the Head-Fi community do not have the problem I do, with buds, they fit perfectly fine, or are willing to pay a bit more for accessories that help with the fit. I am not one of those that will do that.
The Sound
Sources:
During burn in, I used the Fiio’s mainly through my iPhone 6+, playing music all night, then a good solid 16 hours of pink noise. I also played these through my excellent Fiio X3ii, and A3 amp. Kind of a Fiio tri-fecta, if you will. Also used with my iPhone was the small Fiio E6 amp. A nice little amp which, can give your Smartphone that little bit of “oomph” if needed.
Music chosen:
Long Black Veil-Johnny Cash
Every Street-Dire Straits
Oya Mamacita-Los Lonely Boys
Don’t Drink the Water-Dave Matthews Band
Cold Shot-Stevie Ray Vaughan
The Scientist-Coldplay
Clocks-Coldplay
Adventure of A Lifetime-Coldplay
Set Fire to the Rain-Adele
He Won’t Go-Adele
Lazarus-David Bowie
Senorita-Los Lonely Boys
*
Many Others!*
Initial:
My first impression was that it is hard to believe this cost $10…but it was a tempered “believe”…I often garner a first impression which can taint further judgment of my phones. My relationship with the excellent MEE Audio Pinnacle P1’s is a case in point. I REALLY did not like them upon my initial several hours. But, after approximately 50+ hours, they are simply fantastic, and I won’t give them up.
The EM-3’s on the other hand had a much happier beginning. I liked them right out of the box, but tempered with a slightly veiled sound. Let’s be honest. When most people (please don’t take this as elitism) purchase headphones, they are looking for affordable eadbud/IEM’s which they can just plug and play. Burning in the latest/greatest product is not on their mind. They simply want sound. I am happy to report, that the EM’s would pass this test. A decent full sound, which was not too forward, not too overpowering was had with my initial hours listenings. I was happy.
Overall:
I am enjoying the Fiio’s with full foam covers as I write this. I very rarely use full foam covers. I feel that the covers temper the sound too much for my personal taste. I am also happy to report, that using the foam cover allows the bud to stay in my ear much better. The highs are brought down a level, but do not cover them. Listening to Adele’s wonderful
Set Fire to the Rain is quite nice. Her voice carries through the foam nicely, much like looking through a fine satin sheet at a wonderfully backlit scene. You very much enjoy the unencumbered view, but looking through the veiled/satin scene is simply serene. The EM-3 just does not disappoint when it comes to the sound. Bass is solid and tight, mids are where they should be to me, a support of the overall sound. Treble is present, making its note heard, but not overly so…just a hint of “look at me” comes from the highs, and the bass/mids do not mind. A thoroughly satisfying sound from an economical earbud.
Bass:
This is by no means a basshead bud, but it does not shy away from bass. This would be the equivalent of a Mazda Miata showing up on a fine canyon road to engross itself in the twists and curves. Certainly not the fastest, but enough to earn the respect of others present and put a smile on your face. Bass is there, with a roll off just shy of deep bass, but certainly present. Enough bass to satisfy the casual user looking for a Samsung/Apple replacement bud. Tight enough for the seasoned audio aficionado.
Mids:
As stated above, the mids are definitely present, but not overbearing. Too often (in my short review history…) the mid sound is pushed very far forward and the main part of the headphone. I’m not sure if the respective manufacturers are pushing this as a selling point of their buds, or it is a sound consumers demand/like; but I am very satisfied with the slightly recessed mids of the Fiio's. That said, on Coldplay’s very dance-worthy
Adventure Of A Lifetime, the mids take center stage. They do so, because the musician WANTED them to. Besides DEEP bass, it is the mids that take center stage in a dance room. The Fiio’s do not disappoint, providing just what the musicians want. Bass is there, but mids take the front in this song. A solid sound, which is not overpowering. Another song which highlights the mids is the powerful
Oye Mamacita song from Los Lonely Boys. If any group can bring out the limitations of a headphone, I would put Los Lonely right up there. From their varied guitar licks, to the piercing vocals, they run almost the full gamut of a testers dream. I am happy to report, that even with the full foam, the 3’s do not disappoint. Good solid sound.
Treble:
From my limited experience, the treble of inexpensive headphones is the easiest to screw up, either sounding way to bright and sibilant, or lacking completely. The included Samsung is a case of the former, and the current Apple buds the latter. The 3’s best both by being just right. Not bright, certainly not sibilant, but announcing their presence with that aforementioned slight “look at me” sound. Never too bright (and my ears are sensitive to that), Fiio has managed to get this just right. I will not say perfect, but quite good, regardless of the price. Cymbal clash is where it should be; either at the front if the song asks, or as support to the vocals. Not once did I experience sibilance. A worthy sound from the highs, especially with sensitive ears.
Soundstage/Separation:
I like a wide soundstage. As stated in my other reviews, my home system has a sound stage the size of New York to Boston (almost…), and I like it this way. Good separation of instruments, gives my aging ears the ability to hear and separate instruments, hearing all, which are present. If the recording jumbles all sounds together, then that is what the Fiio’s present. Not the fault of the headphones. While the soundstage is wide, it is not Dunu Titan 1 or Pinnacle P1 wide. I had no expectation of that going in, so I was pleasantly surprised with what I did find. A nice fairly wide sound which can be enjoyed. Especially when you can envision by the sound where the instruments are on stage such as with Los Lonely Boy’s live
Senorita from Colorado Springs. The drums are behind the acoustic guitars as support and they should be. Intimate, yet wide enough to enhance your sound to imagine that you were there. I won’t say front row, but I have always found those seats overpriced anyway! A good seat well within the imagination of all present. That is how I would describe the EM’s.
Isolation:
This is one of the few down sides of the EM-3’s, I would say. While these are in no way meant to be completely isolated, the sound leakage means that using them at higher volume would hinder your friends in a quiet environment. Also the outside sound can be heard. This means you must turn the volume up to counteract that…a cycle which might be repeated. These would work for commuting, and active sports where you would like to hear the outside world for safety’s sake, but a definite hindrance in quiet settings.
Presentation:
For $10, these are quite good. Expect for complicated music. This is the biggest falling down of the buds. With complicated music, the sound can get lost, and distracted. This is also my main reason for downgrading these overall. This reminds me of the Bill Nye episode of Electrons in one of his Weather videos…the Electrons are all jumping around in the elevator, as he explainsthe concept of lightning and when the door opens, they scatter every which way….This is what happens when the Fiio’s are asked to accommodate complex music. This does not happen often, and it is not a deal breaker, but it does happen.
Comparisons:
The natural competitors are the supplied earbuds of Smartphones, along with the $5 VE Monk. I fell for the Monk train, and am quite smitten with them, even though I cannot get a good fit due to their size.
Fiio EM-3 vs Samsung supplied:
The Fiio is the clear winner here…no contest. While the supplied Samsung’s are a decent headphone (my daughter really likes hers which is OK with me, they are not nearly as complete as the Fiio. Overly-bright is how I would describe the Samsung’s. Not that bad, but certainly not in the same class as the Fiio’s. That bright sound overshadows all other sound, to the point where almost all you hear is the highs. Soundstage is narrow, mids are non-existent, and bass is on the light side. Just a cheap throw in for those that want immediate sound. The Samsung’s do not fit my ear well, either.
Fiio EM-3 vs Apple supplied:
Again, a pretty clear winner here. The only part where the Apple’s trump the Fiio’s is the deep bass, but at the cost of sound. As overly bright as the Samsung treble was, that is how overbearing the bass is with the Apple’s. Where the Fiio manages to make the bass part of the overall sound, the Apple's shout BASS, BASS, BASS, at the expense of everything else. To me, if they toned down the bass, this would not be that bad of a sound. But it is just too much to bear. Fit is better than the Fiio’s, and less fatiguing over time, but the sound is just not up to the par of the EM’s.
Fiio EM-3 vs VE Monk
And now the one you all turned in for…as did I when I found out that I was lucky enough to review the EM’s. At half the priceof the Fiio, the Monks really are a bargain, which should be experienced by all who would listen. My daughter really likes her pair, while my son and his girlfriend enjoy them, too. I really think that “gift-giving” should be on the business card, which is included with the Monks. You can read for yourself the excellent, LENGTHY thread dedicated to them on the Head-Fi website (
http://www.head-fi.org/t/783669/venture-electronics-ve-monk-a-5-earbud-that-seriously-deserves-a-place-here).
Listening to Adele’s wonderfully sensuous
He Won’t Go, I am hard pressed, VERY hard pressed to choose between these bargains. While the Monk’s provide slightly more detail, the Fiio’s are a very full, warm sounding bud. The Monks do provide more detail, though. Listen to the above song through both and you will immediately notice the tambourine present with the Monk at the beginning of the song. You overlook that instrument through the Fiio’s. I had to listen three times to make sure, but the Monk clearly brings out the subtle support instruments better than the EM-3’s, but that is counteracted by a slightly less warm sound. The Fiio’s fit my musical taste better, with that warm sound. The Monks are a more open (but not warm) sound to me, and this is truly astonishing. To think that I am debating the finer merits of a $10 bud versus a $5 bud, and having a REALLY hard time, just belies how the industry (and the smaller companies) are trying to provide the maximum sound/$ ratio. I for one am truly happy that this is happening. Both of these would compete and DO compete at prices closer to $50. Respectively 10x and 5x their prices…wow. Those few of you reading this (my hope is it is quite a few!), will probably want me to make a decision here…and I will not. To close this comparison, I will explain in the conclusion…
The Fiio’s do fit my ear better, which is huge to me. Comfort is better, due to the smaller size.
Sound ratings:
Samsung supplied: 6/10-too much treble brings this down significantly.
Apple supplied: 6.5/10—BASS, BASS, BASS brings this down, with better fit.
VE Monk: 8/10-$5…FIVE FRIGGIN’ DOLLARS!!! And sound of IEM’s costing 10x their price.
Fiio EM-3: 8/10…TEN FRIGGIN’ DOLLARS!!! Sound matching the Monks, and buds which cost 5x their price solidify this bud.
Conclusion:
Coming into this review, I thought long about what I wanted to test, and how to test the buds listed. Taking a part from @Brooko, I withheld final judgment until I burned all pairs in. A total of about 16 hours of pink noise, coupled with 50+ hours of music, allowed me (in my mind) to limit my time with them (so I could not judge any of them prematurely) and thus limit painting my judgments either way. All this meant is that I had to put up with my Pinnacle P1’s…oh…darn…
That Fiio is only onto their second in-house bud is a testament to their dedication to the music which we all listen. Running their own version of the excellent Titan 1 (EX-1), allowed them street cred, which garnered more listeners. Many on Head-Fi purchased the EX-1, knowing it was a cooperative effort, and cost less than the Titan’s (which I dearly love). Smart business acumen, while affording time to develop their own buds. And I will say that the EM-3 is definitely something to consider when making the choice to replace the included Smartphone buds. Many reviewers state that they will purchase these as stocking stuffers. I would add that throwing these along with a pair of Monks into anyone’s stocking would bring gleeful child-like delight to those lucky enough to receive them. These are good earbuds…REALLY good. As mentioned on the Head-Fi thread, I let one of my peers listen. She immediately hit an online store to purchase a pair herself…after less than a minute. I have also given her a pair of Monks, which she like too.
I keep mentioning the Monks, not as a disservice to Fiio, but as a compliment to both respective companies. A natural inclination I have learned in my short time back into the head listening arena, is that companies WANT to be compared to the standard bearers, they WANT to know how their product racks up against the latest flavor (which is damn good btw), and consider it a compliment to be mentioned with those said products. That Fiio has made this product for $10, simply means they take their business and sound seriously and genuinely care what we purchase, and why. Good customer relations is almost a foregone era, and I find this refreshing to be thought of as a long-term customer, who can help spread their message. With all of this gibberish writing said, if I had to choose, between the two, I lean towards the Fiio’s. The mix of even warm sound, quality build and especially fit makes this the SLIGHT winner to me. Buy yourself a pair, listen to it, enjoy it for what it is…a $10 earbud which makes you want to enjoy your music more and an entry past the stock earbud/cheap quality dime store junk which too many people purchase. Good stuff, Fiio. My compliments to the Chef.