1. Introduction:
Burson playmate is very close to Burson Swing / Fun pair with respect to sound signature except the missing coaxial input on Playmate.
There is not easy way to differentiate among them so that following statements are considered as the latest revision of Swing/Fun pair and at the same time my first review of Playmate.
Fig.1, Playmate and Fun
However, Playmate’s headphone out is slightly different from headphone jack output of playmate. The sound is fuller and more bodied and somewhat mid centric in comparison to those pair.
I prefer Playmate-headphone amp sound signature where strings and winds are more realistic and I feel being listening to in real concert hall.
I denote that playmate headphone output sound signature portion of the review is written in italic letter.
If those reader who already my review for Swing/Fun combination review, then they can read only statement in italic.
2. Audio chain for review: Stock opamp version, Swing/Fun and Tppping Dx7s/Yulong A18 were used for this review, and headphones are hd800(S) / he-560v3 / Fidelio X2. usb stabilizer of Ifi audio nano usb3.0, are sitting between the digital source and the dac.
3. Musical genre for listening: Classical orchestral music I listened for review is entire sound track of Turandot of Puccini's opera, which has good combination of instrumentals and vocals in various scales so that layers of sounds are felt / reviewed through these chain of audio devices.
As indicated in the review of “Audiofool Reviews” - https://audiofool.reviews/2019/02/04/burson-swing/”- which is very technical for hardware, Burson’s new technology of power management makes their new products independent of DC power supply that is usual noisy SMPS. This fact proves itself when the dac is fed by low noise LPS I cannot detect any difference.
It is very appealing that the operating point frequency of their new “Max Current Power Supply (MCPS)” is set at 170khz instead of just higher than 20 khz of audio band. This might prevent any possibility of higher frequencies of harmonics from folding back into the audio band.
4. Some preliminary listening
According to my memory of Burson’s original Conductor and Soloist, they sounded smooth with details, but they didn’t have enough dynamism, whereas Playmate sounds with high dynamism with much more fun factor like rhythmical and vivid presentation of the sound field that includes those ambient sound around the music. These effects generate holographic nature of sound. I think it is due to the redesign of their new MCPS, and they returned back main stream engineering through feedback control using opamps from their minimalist approach that had been applied to those original Conductor / Soloist.
It is very interesting that single Ess9038 q2m of 2 channel chip can compete against quad or octa core channel chip version dac. I think this balancing of performances between upstream ( dac) and downstream amp, so that the total performance are added up to the equal level of amp alone performance due to fact that downstream section dominates the performance of overall system and proved as followings:
It reminds me of Schiit's claim that 32 bit resolution of dac is simply a joke when they introduced Yggdrasil dac of 21 bit supported by their special closed form filters, those combination of which surpasses many top-class dacs (of 32bit) of that time. This indicates that we are not hearing dac chip alone but every cascaded connections .ie. system.
Playmate / Fun has defined bass in good texture and extended treble in keeping graininess to the minimum.
I am not much care of staging but seems good for movie or game so that it provides enough sense of space.
Playmate headphone output has more bodied, fuller, richer, and more organic than any other pairs like Topping dx7s /Yulong A18. In comparison to Playmate (preamp) or Swing / Fun pair, highs are more refined and sense of dispersion, so that it is easier with ears.
5. More listening in some comparison:
I tried some combinations of dac / amp, like compared to dx7s and the internal amp, to dx7s as dac and Yulong.
Playmate generates sound field so vivid and spacious that it is immediate differentiating its pair among any combination except Swing / Fun.
While detailed yet maintaining minimized graininess of sound field. You can feel the surrounding around the source. It is engaging and fun and vivid.
For classical orchestral music listening, the most important thing is cohesiveness of sound of big band music with enough details. I think Playmate meets my expectations. Especially through busy section of all the instrumental outburst of sound where all my usual dac and amp pair has its limitation, Playmate does very well.
Presentation of Strings is so realistic and natural where Swing/Fun has more energy that might mask realistic presentation.
Bass presentation in orchestral music in play of contrabass is also exceptional with sense or presence of being seated in real concert hall.
In general, the sound of Playmate/Headphone jack is more onto concert hall presence and natural, where Topping/A18 is clean / crisp but has somewhat artificial in comparison to Playmate/Headphone jack.
This reduced or dispersed or smoothed highs of Playmate allows me relistening to classical orchestral music that has balanced weight between strings and winds, one of which is symphony 7 of Beethoven. The play of the music is really appealing and amazing, where now winds are solid places on the sonic landscape of the huge orchestral instrument layout.
Now winds are distinct but harmonious among sound field.
Fig.2, Other audio dac / amp for comparison
I think this balance is significant thing for those who are looking for smooth sound especially in highs of strings. But this is almost impossible to get the smoothness everywhere and every time on those areas. Because the grainy nature of the music in highs are depending on our freshness of our bio-hearing system. For example the first time listening to classical music ( maybe any instrumental music) after long time absence of wideband sonic information, the music is really grain free and buttery smooth, and this quality does not stay long enough after having fatigued in an hour or so.
That tells that seeking after smoothness or liquid quality is something difficult or next to impossible job.
However if you looking for balanced sonic quality such as balance between string and wind, then Playmate can be an answer. That balance is more stable and tangible than the smoothness of the music that may be there in some certainty but there is no guarantee that you can get it from music.
Playmate can easily resolve down to details and at the same time the outburst is listenable indeed with cohesiveness and enough energy without sense of clamping due to being congested-ness due to the unresolved outburst of big-band sound.
I tested with He-560 V3 and the result is amazing. The generic liquidity of planar is now enhanced to the highs where planar liquidity has trouble to its highest end. But with Playmate has success in that area and I enjoyed the grain free highs.
With HD800/S Playmate gives more sense of space and ambient quality around sound source with no sense of brightness compared to any other pairs. There is every detail with lushness as is felt in planar.
Tonal balance is spot on, and orchestration of big band is now vivid and detailed without grainy.
With Fidelio X2, the combination removes the sibilant nature of the phone in the upper highs which is always trouble with my usual gears. Now X2 has controlled highs or less fatiguing than any other pairs and sligtly better than Swing/Fun.
6. Audio listening with system as in a dac as a node in system:
Fig.3, Head-fi as a system
We all hear all those nodes and links that forms audio chain, so that my comparison is limited, but Swing with what I have now is the best among my current gears.
Stock form of Playmate is so good that I want to upgrade to discreet opamps to see what degree they can push the boundary of sonic field. Because the stock opamp has known limitation for band-width and the power due to entirely current mode operation inside whereas discrete one can be optimized by external passive components which are not allowed in IC form opamp.
7. A final thought
Playmate has better and natural presentation for highs and lows, especially mids that attract me more so that it makes more organic and pleasant without sacrificing other good natures of liquidity and rhythmic nature.
The most important improvement in Playmate is getting balance in sonic field where everything can be shown layer after layer of sonic fields.
Especially large orchestral classical music, the balance nature is more important than liquidity, and edged details which are formed by emphasized high-notes. And hence high note based detailed sounding might mask the real presence of mid key based instrument.
I should put a comment that feature of the remote is so weak that it does not help much for clumsy effort to change filter / connection rather than simply volume changes.
Burson playmate is very close to Burson Swing / Fun pair with respect to sound signature except the missing coaxial input on Playmate.
There is not easy way to differentiate among them so that following statements are considered as the latest revision of Swing/Fun pair and at the same time my first review of Playmate.
Fig.1, Playmate and Fun
However, Playmate’s headphone out is slightly different from headphone jack output of playmate. The sound is fuller and more bodied and somewhat mid centric in comparison to those pair.
I prefer Playmate-headphone amp sound signature where strings and winds are more realistic and I feel being listening to in real concert hall.
I denote that playmate headphone output sound signature portion of the review is written in italic letter.
If those reader who already my review for Swing/Fun combination review, then they can read only statement in italic.
2. Audio chain for review: Stock opamp version, Swing/Fun and Tppping Dx7s/Yulong A18 were used for this review, and headphones are hd800(S) / he-560v3 / Fidelio X2. usb stabilizer of Ifi audio nano usb3.0, are sitting between the digital source and the dac.
3. Musical genre for listening: Classical orchestral music I listened for review is entire sound track of Turandot of Puccini's opera, which has good combination of instrumentals and vocals in various scales so that layers of sounds are felt / reviewed through these chain of audio devices.
As indicated in the review of “Audiofool Reviews” - https://audiofool.reviews/2019/02/04/burson-swing/”- which is very technical for hardware, Burson’s new technology of power management makes their new products independent of DC power supply that is usual noisy SMPS. This fact proves itself when the dac is fed by low noise LPS I cannot detect any difference.
It is very appealing that the operating point frequency of their new “Max Current Power Supply (MCPS)” is set at 170khz instead of just higher than 20 khz of audio band. This might prevent any possibility of higher frequencies of harmonics from folding back into the audio band.
4. Some preliminary listening
According to my memory of Burson’s original Conductor and Soloist, they sounded smooth with details, but they didn’t have enough dynamism, whereas Playmate sounds with high dynamism with much more fun factor like rhythmical and vivid presentation of the sound field that includes those ambient sound around the music. These effects generate holographic nature of sound. I think it is due to the redesign of their new MCPS, and they returned back main stream engineering through feedback control using opamps from their minimalist approach that had been applied to those original Conductor / Soloist.
It is very interesting that single Ess9038 q2m of 2 channel chip can compete against quad or octa core channel chip version dac. I think this balancing of performances between upstream ( dac) and downstream amp, so that the total performance are added up to the equal level of amp alone performance due to fact that downstream section dominates the performance of overall system and proved as followings:
It reminds me of Schiit's claim that 32 bit resolution of dac is simply a joke when they introduced Yggdrasil dac of 21 bit supported by their special closed form filters, those combination of which surpasses many top-class dacs (of 32bit) of that time. This indicates that we are not hearing dac chip alone but every cascaded connections .ie. system.
Playmate / Fun has defined bass in good texture and extended treble in keeping graininess to the minimum.
I am not much care of staging but seems good for movie or game so that it provides enough sense of space.
Playmate headphone output has more bodied, fuller, richer, and more organic than any other pairs like Topping dx7s /Yulong A18. In comparison to Playmate (preamp) or Swing / Fun pair, highs are more refined and sense of dispersion, so that it is easier with ears.
5. More listening in some comparison:
I tried some combinations of dac / amp, like compared to dx7s and the internal amp, to dx7s as dac and Yulong.
Playmate generates sound field so vivid and spacious that it is immediate differentiating its pair among any combination except Swing / Fun.
While detailed yet maintaining minimized graininess of sound field. You can feel the surrounding around the source. It is engaging and fun and vivid.
For classical orchestral music listening, the most important thing is cohesiveness of sound of big band music with enough details. I think Playmate meets my expectations. Especially through busy section of all the instrumental outburst of sound where all my usual dac and amp pair has its limitation, Playmate does very well.
Presentation of Strings is so realistic and natural where Swing/Fun has more energy that might mask realistic presentation.
Bass presentation in orchestral music in play of contrabass is also exceptional with sense or presence of being seated in real concert hall.
In general, the sound of Playmate/Headphone jack is more onto concert hall presence and natural, where Topping/A18 is clean / crisp but has somewhat artificial in comparison to Playmate/Headphone jack.
This reduced or dispersed or smoothed highs of Playmate allows me relistening to classical orchestral music that has balanced weight between strings and winds, one of which is symphony 7 of Beethoven. The play of the music is really appealing and amazing, where now winds are solid places on the sonic landscape of the huge orchestral instrument layout.
Now winds are distinct but harmonious among sound field.
Fig.2, Other audio dac / amp for comparison
I think this balance is significant thing for those who are looking for smooth sound especially in highs of strings. But this is almost impossible to get the smoothness everywhere and every time on those areas. Because the grainy nature of the music in highs are depending on our freshness of our bio-hearing system. For example the first time listening to classical music ( maybe any instrumental music) after long time absence of wideband sonic information, the music is really grain free and buttery smooth, and this quality does not stay long enough after having fatigued in an hour or so.
That tells that seeking after smoothness or liquid quality is something difficult or next to impossible job.
However if you looking for balanced sonic quality such as balance between string and wind, then Playmate can be an answer. That balance is more stable and tangible than the smoothness of the music that may be there in some certainty but there is no guarantee that you can get it from music.
Playmate can easily resolve down to details and at the same time the outburst is listenable indeed with cohesiveness and enough energy without sense of clamping due to being congested-ness due to the unresolved outburst of big-band sound.
I tested with He-560 V3 and the result is amazing. The generic liquidity of planar is now enhanced to the highs where planar liquidity has trouble to its highest end. But with Playmate has success in that area and I enjoyed the grain free highs.
With HD800/S Playmate gives more sense of space and ambient quality around sound source with no sense of brightness compared to any other pairs. There is every detail with lushness as is felt in planar.
Tonal balance is spot on, and orchestration of big band is now vivid and detailed without grainy.
With Fidelio X2, the combination removes the sibilant nature of the phone in the upper highs which is always trouble with my usual gears. Now X2 has controlled highs or less fatiguing than any other pairs and sligtly better than Swing/Fun.
6. Audio listening with system as in a dac as a node in system:
Fig.3, Head-fi as a system
We all hear all those nodes and links that forms audio chain, so that my comparison is limited, but Swing with what I have now is the best among my current gears.
Stock form of Playmate is so good that I want to upgrade to discreet opamps to see what degree they can push the boundary of sonic field. Because the stock opamp has known limitation for band-width and the power due to entirely current mode operation inside whereas discrete one can be optimized by external passive components which are not allowed in IC form opamp.
7. A final thought
Playmate has better and natural presentation for highs and lows, especially mids that attract me more so that it makes more organic and pleasant without sacrificing other good natures of liquidity and rhythmic nature.
The most important improvement in Playmate is getting balance in sonic field where everything can be shown layer after layer of sonic fields.
Especially large orchestral classical music, the balance nature is more important than liquidity, and edged details which are formed by emphasized high-notes. And hence high note based detailed sounding might mask the real presence of mid key based instrument.
I should put a comment that feature of the remote is so weak that it does not help much for clumsy effort to change filter / connection rather than simply volume changes.