Cant offer any wood to wood comparisons yet, but i have been giving my Stellia's one last listen back to back with my monkey pod VCs before they go.
After some initial A/B'ing sessions with the two pairs, i've spent the last month or so listening solely to the VC's, but coming back to the Stellias over the last few days, i have to say when it comes to performance and enjoyment it is comparatively a much closer run thing and is really more a question of preferences rather one being objectively superior of inferior than the other
The two headphones couldn't be more different from one another, almost in every way, from they look to the way the sit on your head and of course to how they sound. When i consider their respective TOTL price tags it comes as some relief that i find they perform at similar very high level, so if i could afford to i would keep both.
To my ears and for my preferences, the highlight/ benefits of one over the other are (listening direct out of hugo2 and via hugo2 with FA Euforia Tube amp, VCs with the stock pads and both using a 22awg 4 core Neotech UPOCC Silver Cable).
Both pairs are very good at everything. The VC's have richer, warmer (side of neutral), fuller, slightly darker but still highly detailed and super musical natural presentation, whereas the Stellias are closer to being tonally neutral, more forward, brighter, precise super dynamic, but musical way of doing things.
VC Pros:
- Almost mistakable for an open back - Height, width and depth of sound stage are incredible
- Visceral impact across the whole frequency range (except sometimes with the mids)
- Seperation and layering
- Lovely full bass plenty impact and quantity
- Airiness at the top
- Super comfortable
VC Cons:
- Mids can sound a little recessed
- Marginally less detailed, but superior seperation within a bigger stage provides better real world resolution. ie i can here more of the detail more of the time
- Massive on the head (but not heavy)
- Dont shoot me and this is entirely a personal preference, but i prefer the machined cutting edge feel of the stellia's over the artisanal finish of the VCs
Stellia Pros:
- Overall Clarity and resolution (but only just)
- Bass detail
- Stunning mids especially in vocals and guitars with which i prefer the crunch and texture
- Speed and dynamism (but only just)
- Cutting edge design and use of material, compact less obtrusive on the head
Stellia Cons:
- Relatively shallow 2D staging/
- Cutting edge design and use of materials are slightly fragile in real world usage.
- Linear bass (goes deep but lacks the kick of the VCs)
- ginger.
A lot of these findings or at least the pattern, is similar to those that i found with the Utopia's versus the LCD4z, they just did things very differently, pleasing my preference slightly more in certain areas, and i loved them both.
This exercise has confirmed three things in my mind at least: One, these two pairs of headphones are for my money the best CBs ive heard as of today, by some distance and are right up there with the best HPs i've heard of any type. Second this process has re-affirmed that i am susceptible to new toy syndrome, having on arrival of the VCs, dropped the Stellia's like a stone, convinced they were vastly inferior, only to find a month or so later that they're level of performance to my ears at least is pretty even, and finally that i prefer listening to my music through the VCs.
As you can probably tell, i had some really important work i should have been doing this afternoon