Hello everyone, Getting back into head-fi after a few years and looking for one headphone to use with my music collection.
I thought i was all set to go for focal radiance (i odnt need lcose but the descriptions were pretty good) but then I read about hifiman arya and hifiman he1000 stealth. and the fostex 909 and now this one the open atrium.
My favourite genres are classical (piano/guitar) and singer/songwriter but i listento all kinds of music.
I love soundstage and good imaging. I have never heard a zmf headphone before.
Can anyone help me relate these to focal, fostex of hifiman products? I know some of these are planar and some of these are closed.
I would be using these with a solid state amp possible hifiman ef600 or ifi audio diablo or micro idsd signature.
Thanks in advance for any help/advice
Greetings, Anouk,
I can only speak to HEK vs ZMF — haven’t heard a Fostex for a long time (nor from a great chain).
I own Auteur Classic & Atrium, as well as an HEKse. I previously owned an HEKv2 which I sold when I bought the HEKse.
To me, the HEKs were pretty close, with the se being a little warmer, with fuller mids vs the v2. But they were fairly close, and from impressions I’ve read, I don’t think the Stealth edition will be very different either.
Given all that throat clearing … when you said Classical, I thought Hifiman, but then I saw ‘piano/guitar’. My HEKs are/were headstage kings — only a bit less expansive than HD-800, which is great for orchestral music. Most of my Classical listening is Romantic symphonies, concertos, ballets, etc. and while I can enjoy that music from Atrium, I prefer HEK for it.
But for solo instrument or small ensemble (say string quartet) Atrium stage is great. (To be clear, Atrium imaging is great, but I prefer the more expansive stage for orchestral.)
Which really gets us to tonality and technicalities. And there it comes down to personal preferences. HEK are more technical — you’re gonna hear
everything from them. Atrium are no slouch in technicalities, but are still a notch below the HEK. HEK also seem faster, both on attack and decay. And that difference is significant enough that I frequently change filters on my DACs (filter 1 for ZMFs, filter 3 or 4 for HEK on my TT2) and it’s the only case where I’ve heard a noticeable difference from different filters.
To me, the ace in all this is vocals, and to my ears, Atrium has the high hand. Vocals are very good from my HEKse, but they literally drip emotion from my Atrium. Plus, I enjoy high-pitched female vocals more from Atrium. I wouldn’t call HEK sibilant, but some voices (Joni Mitchell, Marisa Nadler) can be somewhat piercing/strident.
Aside: I had a Meze Elite and Atrium concurrently and had a very hard time choosing between them. A big part of that was the fact that Elite (besides being supremely comfortable) produced vocals which were every bit as great as Atrium’s.
Hope that helps
