bkelly
100+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- May 26, 2002
- Posts
- 427
- Likes
- 0
Kelly,
Your comments are a little more difficult to answer. First off let me say that ideally I could easily use two different headphones setups. One cold-bloodedly accurate and the second charming to listen to. My favorite setup that I've heard so far, all things considered, is the Cary with the HD600's w/Cardas cable. It wasn't the most accurate or revealig thing I've ever heard but it was beautiful and if I had the money I would already have one.
When I first got into this headphone thing I was kind of hoping to go in that direction since my main speakers sytem is a little on the clinical side. In an ideal world the headphone setup would give me a different look into things than the main speaker. The mains are all transistor powered and I really wanted to go for the tube sound in my headphnhes system. That's why I've contacted you about the RKV. For my purposes the Melos is just not enough of what I want to hear. It is a great amp though. I ultimately want something like the Cary/HD600 setup at about a fourth of the price. Althugh I think the 590's are very worthwhile and should be seriously considerd by anyone looking in the under $500.00 range they are not the ultimate to me. I'm eventually hoping to do better.
I just fend for the 590's becasue I think they are high quality headphones and have been improperly and unfairly criticised and honestly I suspect it has been for reasons that have nothing to do with the way they sound. User sites like these should be about getting at the truth about different products. That's all I am trying to do. I'll skip any discussion about what is truth, the real meaning of truth and how true is truth anyway becasue I think everyone knows what I mean.
I haven't looked at my former posts but I don't think I have said that the 590's were flat. If I did it was in a weak moment. What I am trying to say is that on my system with the 600's in stock trim the 590' present a noticaebaly more realistic presentation of what the instruments really sound like.
The problem in comparing these two phones is they are characteristacally different (although they do sound like they came form the same family to me, in no way does the 590 sound like an AKG for an example). The 590's sins are ones of commision (detractors claim that they are too bright, too forward and too agressive) while the 600 hundreds sins are primarilly ones of ommison ( upper mid recesion, too veiled and a rolled off top end). For me and I'm sure a ton of other people I prefer a little excess for very critical listening and during the process of listening I just sort of take that into consideration and mentally edit it out. Reversely though I think you'll agree that is quite a bit more difficult to edit back into the recording things you are not hearing to begin with. For this reason alone I clearly prefer the 590 so far. With a cable swap things may be different. We will see.
Forgetting the 590 vs 600 debate I don't know that much about the HP-1000's. Aren't those discontinued. Right now I'm trying to buy a pair of RS-1's to try out.
ON your recommendation I'll definitely look for the Beyerdynamics.
Well, that's it for me. Got to run.
Best
Brian
Your comments are a little more difficult to answer. First off let me say that ideally I could easily use two different headphones setups. One cold-bloodedly accurate and the second charming to listen to. My favorite setup that I've heard so far, all things considered, is the Cary with the HD600's w/Cardas cable. It wasn't the most accurate or revealig thing I've ever heard but it was beautiful and if I had the money I would already have one.
When I first got into this headphone thing I was kind of hoping to go in that direction since my main speakers sytem is a little on the clinical side. In an ideal world the headphone setup would give me a different look into things than the main speaker. The mains are all transistor powered and I really wanted to go for the tube sound in my headphnhes system. That's why I've contacted you about the RKV. For my purposes the Melos is just not enough of what I want to hear. It is a great amp though. I ultimately want something like the Cary/HD600 setup at about a fourth of the price. Althugh I think the 590's are very worthwhile and should be seriously considerd by anyone looking in the under $500.00 range they are not the ultimate to me. I'm eventually hoping to do better.
I just fend for the 590's becasue I think they are high quality headphones and have been improperly and unfairly criticised and honestly I suspect it has been for reasons that have nothing to do with the way they sound. User sites like these should be about getting at the truth about different products. That's all I am trying to do. I'll skip any discussion about what is truth, the real meaning of truth and how true is truth anyway becasue I think everyone knows what I mean.
I haven't looked at my former posts but I don't think I have said that the 590's were flat. If I did it was in a weak moment. What I am trying to say is that on my system with the 600's in stock trim the 590' present a noticaebaly more realistic presentation of what the instruments really sound like.
The problem in comparing these two phones is they are characteristacally different (although they do sound like they came form the same family to me, in no way does the 590 sound like an AKG for an example). The 590's sins are ones of commision (detractors claim that they are too bright, too forward and too agressive) while the 600 hundreds sins are primarilly ones of ommison ( upper mid recesion, too veiled and a rolled off top end). For me and I'm sure a ton of other people I prefer a little excess for very critical listening and during the process of listening I just sort of take that into consideration and mentally edit it out. Reversely though I think you'll agree that is quite a bit more difficult to edit back into the recording things you are not hearing to begin with. For this reason alone I clearly prefer the 590 so far. With a cable swap things may be different. We will see.
Forgetting the 590 vs 600 debate I don't know that much about the HP-1000's. Aren't those discontinued. Right now I'm trying to buy a pair of RS-1's to try out.
ON your recommendation I'll definitely look for the Beyerdynamics.
Well, that's it for me. Got to run.
Best
Brian