Ishcabible
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Jan 19, 2009
- Posts
- 6,371
- Likes
- 839
Many thanks for a thought-provoking review. Your observation towards the end - that the process of grappling with the Yamaha presentation was actually a useful process - really struck a chord with me - I found it required unusually close consideration of my own expectations and preferences. Like you, it seems, I can't find much to like about the Yamaha - but I remain impressed by the apparent determination of Yamaha to try a different approach. And I believe I really can hear some of these idiosyncratic elements jostling in the mix - with dire results to my ear - but striking, nonetheless. As someone who doesn't generally care for planars, I feel the attempt to escape the usual signature is particularly interesting - even though the result is disappointing (to me at least).
This is exactly how I feel actually. The Elite, LCD5, Solitaire, D8000 Pro, and Susvara generally shared the same “soundstage dip” into upper midrange rise and elevated upper treble, just to varying degrees. While the YH5000SE doesn’t agree with my preferences, I do respect that they did something different. The Caldera is my flagship planar of choice currently because it doesn’t do the things I normally dislike about planars.