It would probably be my favorite album by The Who if I had never heard it. However, it is the most overplayed album by The Who. It's absolutely inescapable on classic rock radio. It's The Who album that is completely unavoidable, like it or not. For that reason, I've been preferring "The Who By Numbers," "Quadrophenia," and "Tommy," and just about anything else besides "Who's Next" for years. Luckily, there is some really cool stuff like "My Wife" on "Who's Next" that hasn't been overplayed and still makes it tolerable...
+1-if you look on Amazon you'll see the following order (in popularity):
1. The Ultimate Collection-2 disc box set spanning their entire career that was remastered in 2002
2. Who's Next
3. Tommy
4. Quadrophenia-2011 duluxe remastering which I've seen well reviewed in terms of the remastering
FWIW-I bought a bunch of classic rock this year putting together a classic rock library of sorts and went bought The Ultimate Collection and Quadrophenia. That gives me most of their music I want. The Ultimate Collection has early stuff, 3 songs from Tommy, 5 from Who's Next and 3 from Quadrophenia.
We all have different priorities. For me, a child of the 70's a teen and young adult of the 80's I have heard soooo much classic rock radio that just about every song on Who's Next I've heard to death. I could say the same thing about much of the Doors music. Similarly, I'm a big Zeppelin fan, but I have zero desire to own Zep IV for the same reasons.
I'd go with Quadrophenia as the most under appreciated-and honestly Quad gets a fair amount of love. The overall arranging, repetition of rock operish elements of Quad is masterful. Plus, many of the songs other than Love Rein... weren't played to death.
Since I bought a large amount of classic rock over a few months, I cut my loses and went with some compilations.
I think this is an impressive collection. There are some that have complained about the remastering....but I'm in it for the songs and for a single collection, it's hard not to be impressed by the track list. For anyone wanting a single collection-IMO this is the one.
Here's the track list:
~~Disc 1:
1. I Can't Explain
2. Anyway, Anyhow, Anywhere (Mono Version) 2
3. My Generation (Original Mono Version)
4. The Kids Are Alright (Edit Mono Version)
5. A Legal Matter (Mono Version)
6. Substitute
7. I'm A Boy (Original Stereo Version)
8. Boris The Spider (Mono Version)
9. Happy Jack 2:10
10. Pictures Of Lily
11. I Can See For Miles
12. Call Me Lightning
13. Magic Bus (Original Stereo Version)
14. Pinball Wizard (Original Version)
15. I'm Free (Original Studio Version)
16. See Me, Feel Me
17. The Seeker (Edit)
18. Summertime Blues (Original Live At Leeds Version)
19. My Wife (Original Version)
20. Baba O'Riley (Original Version)
21. Bargain 5:35
Disc 2:
1. Behind Blue Eyes (Original Version) 3:42
2. Won't Get Fooled Again (Original Version) 8:31
3. Let's See Action 3:58
4. Pure And Easy 5:21
5. Join Together 4:21
6. Long Live Rock 3:54
7. The Real Me 3:30
8. 5:15 [Explicit] 4:50
9. Love Reign O'er Me 5:50
10. Squeeze Box 2:40
11. Who Are You 6:21
12. Sister Disco
13. You Better You Bet
14. Eminence Front