In response to
@Skyediver s’ original post,
I place headphone listening second to home hifi, and so will not give it the budget that it may deserve.
My headphones are chosen as supplemental to the ultimate audio rig for speakers at home.(hifi is a hobby I enjoy, equal to photography and above computing tech)
The audio rigs in the house cover a nice Vinyl setup, several surround setups (some small, some grand), and a nice 2 channel setup for feeding the house music.. (there are a few other 2 channel rigs scattered around the house, and I am not afraid of using paired bluetooth ‘speakers as soccer goal posts’ down at the park).
I choose to completely ignore my car audio setup, but will happily feed it from good sources, whether than means a high quality portable DAP (and possibly DAC) or Vinyl recorded to tape (don’t knock it till you’ve tried it,.. flogs the six stack CD player in a ‘high end’ default car setup).. True,.. having nice parts chosen for headphone sound can greatly augment car-fi..
The home stereo rigs get all the focus, as I raised the firstborn from early on to sleep during sound around the house. So I am lucky in that I can do late night TV watching with the surround sound and not in ‘midnight mode’. To be fair we like our home to have bedrooms not up against a theatre zone etc.
The design, for me, has always been neutral equipment, with speakers/cans tailoring the sound.
Regarding headphones; mostly evolved due to great ‘head-fi’ gaming concepts. Having owned sound cards since the first ones came to market, and many many iterations since (presently use an Asus Xonar Essense STX) stuff like the Aureal Vortex A3D 2.0 was truly amazing and made me realise that I’d always need a ‘good headfi rig’.
I learned at sixteen years of age that the amount of audio that one can get from earbuds and a walkman was phenomenal bang for buck/value for money,.. and that it would be disappointing if at any point in my life I was without at least that much sound quality. (music can free the soul and personal music can allow a person to soar to much ‘happy heights’ anywhere)
SO regarding chasing joy and headphones/hifi as a hobby.....
I like every time my hifi acquisitions can help my head-fi goals. When I bought a Denon DCD-s10, in could be used as a DAC seperate to it being a world class CD player.
I have assembled a few budget rigs where a musical fidelity x-cans (a tube buffer) can preamp some nice vintage power amps etc.. a lot of the kit crosses over.
When evaluating home hifi, I always assess what does it bring to my head-fi rig. Sometimes a purchase omits a need (like buying a Rotel RCD-971 CD player, sans headphone socket), but sometimes it feeds back admirably (a Chord Hugo DAC/preamp)..
Like many I need headphones to cover many bases - especially as I listen to most music genres. Probably less classical than jazz,.. and more 90s rock/ and vintage prog rock than alternative styles and pop. Not enough Country - it just makes me feel ‘hick’ even though it resonates with the heart the most and is calibrated as being the healthiest genre (generally speaking) for our soul. (classical aside).
Heavy metal and rap is the smallest part of my collection, and I don’t own any Bob Marley, but some industrial and ‘heavy stuff’ in the forms of Nine Inch Nails/Tool/a Perfect Circle etc creeps in..
(partly due to being great test stuff for hardware.. I find Nine Inch Nails/Supertramp/Parsons(or Floyd) and some beaut classical stuff as frequent system check discs.
So for gaming I generally need an open back flatline sound (for HRTFs); presently needs met with some AudioTechnica ADG1Xs / Audeze Mobius cans. (the audio technica had a more neutral sound vs some Beyerdynamic T90s which had a bass hump)
For music, like many, I see strengths of different designs.
Having owned some Yamaha Orthodynamics, they didn’t meet ALL my needs, so I moved them on. Then I realised that the best budget friendly way to do headphone sound isn’t ‘one set to rule them all’ but to have differing sets to cover the needs of certain genres.
My child learned this recently, having grown up on some Sennheiser on ear Momentums (whilst being apart of the choir for years, vocals ruled supreme), and turned down many other headphones.. wouldn’t use any of my $500+ price point Sonys’, denied the Bowers and Wilkins P5 and P7 etc.. Then discovered industrial music and fell in love with Meze99s (“its like they were built to do Tool”)
But having a penchant for Tori Amos and Kate Bush etc, has need for other headphones, so also has some Ultrasone cans (mostly for long listening session due to their shielding and ‘technology‘)
I think many people hear the differences between technology types (eg planar and electrostatic),.. and we all have a growth / journey ahead of us when it comes to learning stuff regarding audio (and theory not always equalling reality/reality not always equal to theory)..
I feel most people who listen to classical music or like soundstage (eg gamers or certain genres) are going to want open backs.
People who want to share their living space (eg in bed at night beside a partner) have call for closed backs.
People who want to travel on public transport, or not want to spend the money on equivalent sound quality ‘over ears’ will want IEMs/earbuds.. The amplification ease means that a ‘pocket fi’ rig can really shrink in size.
Oh and Noise Cancelling is a thing, so don’t exclude some nifty headwear in that category
What has thirty years of head-fi pursuit led to for me?
I whittled down fifteen sets of headphones in the last decade..
My primary over ears are some Ultrasone Edition 5
My go to earbuds are some Cardas Ear Speakers
Noise Cancellers would be either some Definitive Technology Symphony 1s (if I can about sound and have a rig), or some Sony 1000s (acceptible for voice calls too)
And to be honest my competitive gaming cans (the ADG1X/Mobius) don’t get much use, probably because the sheer comfort that you get when you fold all your headphone budget into one set to rule them all (my Edition 5 ultrasones’) equals so much comfort that ‘why bother with anything else’.
And if it isn’t comfortable, then no matter how great the sound is, they just wont get worn. (a sad thing I learned with some Audeze Sine on ears)...
So comfort being greater than or equal to sound quality is probably a good weighing. (and don’t knock people for choosing it- they probably are more ‘head-fi’ than we give them credit, simply due to needing to keep a set on their head so often as to put comfort first)
Could I survive on one set?
Nope- I reckon minimum I would need one set ‘studio flatline’ and one set to enjoy music. (to be fair this can be re-equalisation nowadays),.. so I probably could whittle it down.
But then life circumstances change and the ‘open back‘ flatline (eg Hifiman Sundara) will no longer work in a situation it was planned to be in.. So I suppose a closed back set of on ear studios that can be driven from low powered amps, well,.. would be my preference. (and is why that is what I chose as my ultimate set).
Oh, and second hand bargains should never be overlooked whilst all the fools buy flavour of the moment stuff.
When I bought a Vioelectic V100 due to someone ‘upgrading to an O2, made me laugh. Same thing with hifi seperates.. sometimes an golden oldie ‘top tier’ part, will trounce most modern ‘5 star’ flagships.. everything is built to a pricepoint, and stuff gets cheaper to turn more profit/pay more patents..
I suppose headphone evolution really kicked in in the last fifteen years.. but for front end technology.. I’d consider buying stuff that wasn’t made in the last ‘couple of years’ quite happily.
(eg my Questyle QP1R isn’t the newest DAP but as a transport it kills most of the market and are ‘budget’ second hand parts really, whilst I bought mine new, I’ve advocated to ‘many’)