Quote:
Originally Posted by athenaesword /img/forum/go_quote.gif
triplefi for the win! with shure tips on the UEs, they're just as comfy as the se530, and i find that they sound more balanced, with a bigger soundstage than the se530s
|
i personally think that if we are going to put these two phones head to head then the triple fi should not win because it uses a component made for the se530's, i think the se530 are an overall better made set of phones and better thought out.
again the se530 has completely dedicated bass drivers,whereas the triple fi carries the midrange through the bass drivers, this causes quality loss in both the midrange and bass frequencies.
the shures on the other hand carry the midrange through the tweeter so this explains why the highs suffer a little. but not as bad as the mids and bass of the triple fi because the bass drivers damand more movement, causing more quality loss for the mids of the triple fi.
this is why shure gets my vote, its simply more logical to have dedicated bass drivers as bass simply needs to be sepertate to reach good depths. how often do you come across a subwoofer that performs well putting out midrange (not often) this explains why the triple fi mids are not nearly as forward and strong.
dont get me wrong, the triple fi is indeed balanced and clean but i think if anybody was to do a distortion test the mids will start cracking up at serious volume, wheras you should with my theory find the se530 will push on with cleaner output to serious volumes. at reasonable levels tho the triple fi and se530 are dead even on quality terms for me. crank it up and technically the se530 should come out on top.
i am a little biased towards the se530 because i like the realistic smooth warm sound but there is also technical reasoning behind why i think they are better