What kind of woman do you think Crinacle is attracted to? Would you take dating advice from him? Would you believe that some men prefer a full-figured woman? It is possible that they also prefer a slower bass, or natural transients opposed to lightning quick and artificial sounding decay - or vice a versa? I know some men who are into cosmetic surgery/enhancements, and others who prefer a non-modified figure.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and sound quality is in the ear/brain system of the listener. I'm not saying that Crin should be discredited - far from. He does have a lot of experience - but as
@firesign says, he also has personal taste - this is my point. I've seen movies that got horrible reviews from critics (uncut gems) that I thought were actually really good. I've heard IEMs that got 'meh' ratings from crin that I thought were exceptional - Meze Rai Penta for example.
So Crin is a double edge sword in a sense:
- on the one hand, he's protecting consumers by 'calling out' manufacturers for what he feels to be sub-par tuning/technicalities. He does seem genuine and doesn't vacillate or try to polish turds with over-generic praise - I appreciate that!
- on the other, he's potentially limiting the exposure folks have to an IEM that may actually suit them better. He's scaring people away from what could be an excellent match for them and bring them enjoyment.
Even he's said as much - that his work should not be used as the sole factor in buying decisions - you have to know yourself and what you like before you can use his database and reviews effectively.