AManAnd88Keys
500+ Head-Fier
I think that if people stood near a piano or violin played with gusto that they would find them overly bright at times if they were sensitive to treble.
If the amp and the headphones accurately reproduce that level of sound, they naturally tend to blame the amp, headphone or both rather than the source material as the problem area.
Very true. Sharpness / brightness can be a desired part of a record if the musician and/or engineer wants it to be there.