Interesting.
I listen to a lot of Hard Rock and Punk yet since I went balanced I rarely listen ( maybe once) at full volume with my 600's.
Without the balance mode I would agree the HD series sounds muffled and weak
I don't know if you're hearing impaired but saying "The 600's, even balanced, need more power than the Pono can provide to really produce the "Sennheiser sound". is flat out wrong.
Plugging my 600's into my Balanced Pono, Fiio X5ii and LD MLIII Tube Amp all give me the Senny sound.
I'm curious if you also use the bass boost on the Fiio (If it has one)
First, I am not hearing impaired, I just like to listen loud after 20+ years of studio and sound reinforcement duties earlier in my life. My normal studio volume was 90+db, stage mixes up to 120+db. I have my hearing tested yearly and suffer only the normal dropouts of a 66 year-old.
I do not use the bass boost and am generally anti-equalizer. I like the EQ the producer wanted (see studio experience above) and see little need to alter it.
In using the Pono with the 600 's, balanced, I found many albums I was playing at full volume and almost everything else at 90%. Just wanted more headroom. The E12 and Valhalla 2 fit the bill perfectly, even though they are single-ended.
I don't believe I am the only one to have said the Pono is under-powered with 300-600 ohm phones.
OK...we all hear differently.
I'm just saying volume is not a problem for me in balanced mode.
And I like my Rock loud.
Tyll Hertsens is in my opinion the most trustworthy reviewer online and he recommends the 600's for the Pono
in balanced.
Here's a reply/comment from Charlie Hansen (Pono designer and President of Ayre Acoustics) to Tyll's review of the Pono.
I hope I can post this here. (mods let me know)
"Hi Tyll and InnerFidelity readers,
Thanks for the super thorough review on the PonoPlayer. I think the title sums it up perfectly—"Promises Fulfilled". Neil Young's vision of delivering the same experience to the end user that the artist had in the studio is a reality, and it is delivered at an affordable price.
I'll admit that until the PonoPlayer came along, I've not been much of a "headphone guy". While in high-school and neither funds nor space for a "real" stereo, I had a pair of Stax SR-X Mk.II's that received lots of use (LPs and tubed equipment), but that has been roughly 40 years ago.
In the lovely open spirit of the review, let me reveal some of my expectation biases:
1) While in the hospital after the accident that paralyzed me nearly nine years ago, Tyll (then still with HeadRoom) and Jeff Joseph (Joseph Audio) got together and gave me the gift of a pair of Sennheiser HD-600 headphones and a HeadRoom headphone amplifier. I was extremely touched by their generousness (much nicer than flowers, for a guy at least!) and will chalk that up as a positive bias.
I still have those headphones, and rewired for balanced operation (almost a requirement to get good volume levels from high-impedance cans from a portable player where the standard output level is only 1 volt), they are still the main way that I listen to the PonoPlayer.
2) During the review process I've had the pleasure of exchanging several e-mails with Tyll. I've been astounded by his breadth of knowledge and depth of inquiry, and feel I've found something of a kindred spirit in terms of our thirst for exploration. I will also chalk that up to a positive bias.
So if you're not getting the volume
you need...fine.
But as I said saying a blanket statement like the Pono will not push the 600's to full bloom in balanced mode is wrong.
And who's talking about 600ohm?
Last time I checked the 800's were 300.
There's no doubt the Pono is under powered for anything even close to 600.