[snip]
By the way, what do you think about that Oppo with the HD800's? Such a beautiful amp.
I've read several comments from HD800 owners who like the way the HD800 sounds with the OPPO HA-1, using both its ESS9018 DAC and the amp section (which I think is absolutely terrific for planar magnetic headphones), but even when using the Metrum Octave MkII to drive the HA-1's amp, the HD800 still reveals some fatiguing brittleness.
I attribute this brittleness to the OPPO HA-1's use of negative feedback - admittedly because Cees Ruijtenberg (the designer at Metrum) made a compelling argument for using low feedback or zero-feedback amplifier designs, when I told him how pleased I was with the Octave MkII but that I could still hear an edginess in the HD800 treble.
Most tube amps are low-feedback designs - which could explain why even neutral sounding tube amps lack the brittleness that the HD800 can so readily reveal - like the OTL Schiit Valhalla 2 (which is not not dark in the treble, nor in the least bit euphonic in a syrupy way). These inherently low feedback tube amps lack the brittleness that the HD800 can hear in solid state amps with multiple gain stages where lots of feedback is typically applied to control distortion.
As Nelson Pass explains in his white paper on the use of negative feedback, it can indeed reduce measurable distortion, but in doing so, negative feedback can create artifacts of its own that increase the
complexity of the remaining distortion. My LCD-2 rev.1 is insufficiently resolving to reveal this complex, though low-intensity distortion caused by the use of negative feedback in the OPPO HA-1 and in my DACmini CX, for example, but the highly resolving HD800 can reveal it, readily. My Metrum Octave MkII has eliminated the sterility and SABRE sheen (artificial brightness) I was hearing with the OPPO HA-1's ESS9018 DAC and the HD800, but I much prefer using my LCD-2 rev.1 with the OPPO HA-1, to using the HD800, because my LCD-2, with its shelved highs and less resolving planar magnetic drivers, isn't revealing the brittleness that I can still hear with the HD800.
So, I'm still researching low-feedback and zero-feedback solid state amps (as I'm trying to avoid tube rolling). The Audio-gd Master 9 and their new C-2 Class A are both zero-feedback designs. The Master 9 (not suprirsingly?) has a terrific reputation with the HD800, but I'm trying to see if I can find something less expensive -and- the jury is still out on the C-2 Class A. I'm also considering the Metrum Aurix - the Cees Ruijtenberg zero-feedback amp that uses nothing but two transformers for gain (similar to a couple of Nelson Pass's First Watt designs.)
And I'm currently evaluating the very affordable ($350) NuForce HA-200 single-ended Class A amp, which has only been in my possession for 3.5 days, but I can already say it's far nicer with the HD800 than either the OPPO HA-1's amp or the DACmini CX amp. The HA-200 uses negative feedback, but I bought it anyway, because of its price and Mike Mercer's review.
So, despite my having embraced the quest to find an affordable low-feedback or zero-feedback solid state amp, I'm now in possession of an amp (the HA-200) that uses negative feedback but
does not sound brittle with the HD800 - premature though that statement is with it still burning in... But the HA-200 is shaping up to be a great solution for the HD800 and I've not even driven it with the Metrum Octave MkII yet - expressly because I wanted to hear the HA-200's ability to satisfy the HD800's judgement without any help from my NOS DAC. The smoothness and transparency I'm hearing with this $350 HA-200 is not interfering in the least with detail retrieval. Listen to anything by Vangelis, for example, and the HD800 will hear detail that I cannot hear with the HA-1 or DACmini CX amps - it's readily apparent, too. In my opinion, having done a lot of reading on the impact of using negative feedback in amplifier design, I think the folks at NuForce have managed to tune in just the right amount of feedback with the HA-200 to avoid the brittleness I hear with the OPPO HA-1 and DACmini CX, using the HD800. More later...
Take all of this with a grain of salt, as I love the frequency response of my LCD-2 rev. 1 and I don't want to hear any brittleness or edginess in the treble. Surely, those people who are content with the OPPO HA-1 for their HD800s have different tastes -or- they've just not been exposed to anything they personally would find better than what they are hearing now. In other words, you might like the OPPO HA-1 with the HD800 even though I don't. YMMV.
Mike