Actually you are 100% correct I confused reviews between X1 and X2 - thanks guys.
So I have X-Fi Titanium HD and Fidelio X2 now but I've only used them for The Rise Of The Tombraider - surround seems to be working brilliantly as in positioning of enemies is very easy to pinpoint using audio (although I might try closing my eyes next time I play and try positioning them correctly without visual clues if possible).
Windows Speakers control panel allows me to choose 5.1 speakers and the test appears to be positioning the speakers correctly. Am I correct in assuming that the reason I do not have 7.1 here is that I'm using CMSS-3D and not Dolby Headphone (but the 7.1 is virtual only for DH in any case if i had DH hardware)?
However I haven't been able to test my setup to my satisfaction: Rightmark 3DSound only shows "DirectSound 3D" as an option in the system menu (everything else is greyed out) and the test where you can move the sound around the head seems to be only stereo to me and doesn't give convincing surround effect at all for front and rear positioning. Only the right most slider works which I'm assuming is meant to be moving sound up and down in height and that appears to be stereo/not working.
Is Rightmark 3DSound just too old to test this stuff correctly and could you recommend another similar application? Possibly I have something wrong in my setup but like I said surround in games appears to be working very well so far so I'm not sure.
Finally: I would like to have a sub-woofer and headphone surround effects: one way to do this with *stereo* audio is
splitting the audio from the 3.5mm jack and running it to another amp then headphones so headphones and sub have seperate volume levels.
Will this destroy the surround effect? Or is there another way of achieving this?
Also found this which some may find useful: http://satsun.org/audio/ up to date (but going back to the 80's
) list of PC games and surround sound API used.