Quote:
Currently in the market to upgrade the closed HP option in my collection.
My current gear is in my profile. The driver here is to improve SQ and isolation over my ATH-M50's.
If any one can give me an impression of what these offer over the M50's, and how the sound profile compares to the SD-650 (which I like), I would appreciate.
Musical taste: Rock, jazz, pop, classical.
Use for travel, portable use, and isolation from wife's TV when working/playing on the computer.
Thanks!
hey same here! I'm looking to graduate from my m50s
I just did the step up from my m50s to the Mad dogs about a week ago. There is almost no comparison. It's a totally different animal.
Note: I've been using some Beyer velour replacement pads on my m50's for better comfort, but it diminishes the isolation.
Comfort vs m50s
The Mad Dogs are heavier, but the leather comfort strap makes it almost unnoticeable. The isolation on the Mad Dogs w/ Alpha pads is really good. There doesn't seem to be much if any leakage at all, and anyone that wants to talk to me pretty much has to tap me on the shoulder for me to notice that they are even standing there. The pads are like wonderful pillows.
The clamp is still there, but not nearly as bad as the m50s, it is also adjustable if you spend a little time with the band, though a little clamp helps with the bass IMO.
They do get a little warm on my ears after a while, but nothing like the sweat-inducing sauna pads that came with the m50s. For me, the comfort is an 8.5/10. That's saying a lot from me. I'm super sensitive to discomforts as my head is large and so are my ears, so just about anything will set me off.
Build Quality:
They feel solid. I still treat them like I do my 3 month old twins though. Stock cable is thick and sturdy. The new Alpha pads are fantastic and make you feel like you're wearing $1000+ headphones. The stitching seems like it will hold up well. The pads will undoubtedly last much longer than the pleather m50s pads that become brittle and crack.
Sound:
After listening to the Mad Dogs for a week, I finally switched back to my m50s and tested them using the same setup (foobar2k -> Modi -> Magni -> Headphones) and music tracks. My first though was "blah". They sounded muddy and bloated. To be totally honest it was hard to keep listening knowing that I had the Mad Dogs a foot away.
That being said, I still enjoy the m50s for movies, some games, and certain bass heavy genres where I want a hard hitting punch and rumble. Eventually I'll probably sell off the m50s to upgrade to a better V-shaped sounding can. I'm still searching the forums and reviews to get a good idea on what that will be. That being said, it does take a little time to adjust to a new sound signature after listening mostly from my m50s, so make sure to have an open mind (ear?) and let yourself adjust.
Final thoughts:
I searched for weeks to make my decision, and I don't regret the Mad Dogs at all. I do recommend that you have a amp that can properly juice up the Mad Dogs to really get a quality experience. I tried to run them out of my Galaxy s2 with an old airhead portable amp (basically a crap DAC and low-end amp) and the SQ was extremely disappointing, a far far cry from the Majesty that comes from my Magni/Modi.
Hopefully this helps a little with your decision making.