Concerning SQ, I'm sure an audiophile would choose the D2000 over either of the other two because it's more refined. The Pro 900 isn't bad, but it isn't really all that good either. It is quite frankly, in my opinion, overrated.
However, the difference between the likes of D2000 and Pro 900, and the likes of the XB line, is not exactly night and day to me. The step from cheap headphones to $150 ones is much bigger than the step from the XB-910 to D2000 and Pro 900.
I'll try comparing them a bit more though: The D2000 is most "neutral" of the bunch, the Pro 900 the most V-shaped (yeah that dip in the mids is significant) and the XB-910 is the bassiest, by quite a margin. I don't perceive the mids of the XB-910 as especially recessed, nor do I perceive the treble as especially bad. For instance, the XB-500 is much more recessed when it comes to the mids and the treble (really, it's almost just bass), and the Pro 900 is much more recessed in the mids (really, it's basically just bass and treble). The XB-910 has the smallest soundstage of them and the D2000 the biggest (the Pro 900 is weird in this regard, sometimes it feels 3D and sometimes it just sounds very, very, very bad, depending on record etc.), but the XB-910 has a bigger soundstage than for instance M50 or HD25-1 (to give you an idea), comparable to the soundstage of the CAL! The amount of detail is greater on both D2000 and the Pro 900, but since Pro 900 has a piercingly sharp treble it's hard to tell what's detail and what's just a result of that. I don't find the lack of details that big of a deal, but as with everything in this hobby, YMMV.
In my honest opinion, it's a great headphone. I do think it's MSRP of $299 is ridiculous (speaking of MSRPs, yeah Ultrasone, I'm looking at you), I do think most people would favorably choose the D2000 over it and I think they'd make the right choice. That being said, I like it a lot more than the Pro 900 because the only thing I enjoyed more on the Pro 900 is the sharp treble, but other than that the XB-910 is exactly how I want my trap and hiphop delivered (that's what I bought them for in the first place). For everything else I have the D2000 and for commuting the X10.