"The Illusion Approachs Reality" - STAX-009 vs. "S"
Presumably, as one of the few in this illustrious circle, who mainly - but not exclusively - listens to an almost complete tube & analogue chain, my hearing impressions and the resulting opinions are probably one-sided, subjective and therefore not transferable:
But for me it is clear - the 009S is the winner!
(TT with KOETSU platinum cartridge, with Step-Up Trafo, MM-Tube phone stage, and AudioValve Solaris tube head phone amp.)
Compared to the (old) 009, the „S“ conveys this notorious "cliché of an additional layer of music".
Whether the bass is stronger, the attack sharper, etc, I can not judge with my music. The 009 has this hint, what occasionally is called "artificial transparency" ?, "sharpness" ? or "pointed heights" or whatever has been complained about; and that part is missing at the "S", supplemented by what I would call "Euphonic Shine".
In short, the "S" is clearly the more
pleasant, musically correct headphone for me.
My listening music was: (among many others)
(the "Digital Exception") ... a sampler CD "The Art Of Cecilia Bartoli", including a rarely heard version of "Libiamo ne'lieti calici" (Brindisi) by Cecilia Bartoli, with Luciano Pavarotti, Orchestra Sinfonica e Coro di Milano Giuseppe Verdi, Riccardo Chailly
Vinyl: (my all-time standards)
- Bach's Italian Concerto, version with harpsichord with Martha Schuster, a recording that reproduces the harpsichord in splendid tones .. By the way: This is the optimal playground for a STAX !!!
- Age of Belcanto ", with Joan Sutherland & Richard Bonynge
- Moonlight Serenade, with Ray Brown, Bass & Laurindo Almeida, guitar.
New in my analogue collection:
- Dolce Duello: Cecilia Bartoli & Sol Gabetta, cello
- Sol Gabetta - Il Progetto Vivaldi: The winter of the 4 seasons, played on the cello, is simply "magical"
- The Hot Sardines
BTW: For many years, Cecilia Bartoli has been my "reference voice" for any music replay equipment & component reviews. (It is the only "famous" opera singer that I occasionally saw & heard live in Zurich both in opera and concert. Unfortuanley, her music is rare on vinyl)
A note on comfort & handling: The slightly tighter head frame fits my head just fine.
My only objection: STAX could have developed a more elegant solution for the headband. Maybe: even the rotating ear pads and connectors from the "007" would have been just to my taste.
For me:
"Case Closed"
Greetings
Urs
PS:
My comments have to be regarded as " grumbling or praise" on a very high level !
Listeners with other source equipment & (digital ? ) devices might well come to a different conclusion ....
However: a cross check on my office system, where I occasionally listen to rather mediocre digital downloads confirmed my above impression: The “S” beats the old 009 as well.
BUT on some occasions, the little brother – 007 !! - would be the even better choice for such “LOW-Fi material” ….