I got to see a performance of this a few weeks ago live. The spectacle of the the four French horns standing in front of the orchestra is an original and arresting and striking sight. You know you are in for something special. This is a very original work by Schumann, a concerto for four French Horns.
I am not suggesting for a second that anyone listen to all of this. I am just trying to give plenty of resources so the piece is accessible to anyone who is interested.
Rather than me try to write about it I'll just copy the Berlin Philharmonic's web site synopsis:
T
he Konzertstück for Four Horns and Orchestra, the third Schumann work on this programme, is rarely heard, despite its beauty and originality, because it is not easy to find four hornists for the demanding solo parts. As in several other programmes during the 2008/2009 season, compositions by Robert Schumann and Bernd Alois Zimmermann were also juxtaposed in this concert. The Symphony from 1953 is one of Zimmermann’s early works inspired by Arnold Schoenberg, and integrates the elements of the symphonic model with several movements into a single movement. Schumann strived for something similar in his Fourth Symphony. Thus, the two composers on this concert programme resemble each other not only because of their sometimes depressive temperaments but also in their relentless search for new forms.
At the end of the concert I saw they got an encore and the four French horns came back out and played some Star Wars music by themselves--very fun.
I looked for full performances on Youtube that presented the best balance of visuals and music. . . not easy:
This one seems extremely good to me although the horns are placed behind violins and cellos, not what I believe is the conventional place right in front of the orchestra:
This one the audio is nice and punchy but the horns are placed off to the left because of the nature of the venue:
This one seems good too, except again the horns are not lined up horizontally right in front of the orchestra in the way I saw it. This is the most light-hearted performance of the work to me, and I think for that reason it is the performance I personally enjoy the most. The work is dense and serious enough standing on its own, you don't need the orchestra adding even more
gravitas, IMHO. To me this kind of playing of the piece best illuminates the beauty of Schumann's writing:
Below is a world-class version where you can follow along with the music and listen to a first-class performance. Unfortunately for us (but fair enough) it looks like if you want to watch the full video recording of the orchestra you have to pay the Berlin Philharmonic cash money, some kind of subscription or something. They do put up a two-minute teaser on YouTube but it's really just that. . . a teaser to market their subscription service. The audio plus visual quality is spectacular but it looks like it'll cost you 10 or 15 bucks a month at least.
Teaser video from Berlin Philhamonic (you can see how the four horns are in front of the orchestra):
However, even though they don't let you see but two minutes of the video if you don't pay cash money they do let you follow along with the music if you are interested in hearing a world class performance and reading the music along with it. I really enjoy doing this once or twice just to help me correlate what is going on visually in written music with what I am hearing, especially with something this complex. In addition, this is going to be the best audio of any of the full-length options I've provided.
Full world-class performance with music to follow along:
https://www.clip.fail/video/1dsQAac4rWA