TheWuss
Reviewer at Headphone.Guru
I've always been a "studio album" listener. And moreover, I appreciate the craft that goes into the studio album.
And I also feel that this craft most often produces the "definitive version" of a given song.
Sometimes, though, a particular song might reach a new level of power and resonance in live performance. This might be the result of experimenting with a new musical arrangement (Clapton's unplugged Laya, for example), or a moment of cathartic performance, or even both.
A fine example, that I'd like to start with, is Fleetwood Mac's "Big Love".
The version on Tango in the Night is a fine song, and a fine album opener. But, when the song was performed live by Lindsey Buckingham (solo with guitar on The Dance DVD), it seemed to blossom into what I feel is the finest version of the song (and one of the more powerful live performances that I've seen in rock music).
Here's a Youtube video of the original version, followed by the live performance...
I'd love to hear what other people might point to, as great examples of songs that found their definitive voicing when performed live, rather than in the studio...
And I realize that there will be those among us who prefer live recordings in general. And also bands whose reputation as live performers might mean that their live albums are the "go to" document of their music (Phish, for example). But, I'd like to stay away from that subject matter, favoring those more "uncanny", singular live performances that transfixed us, and altered our perception of what the song could be...
Thanks for reading, and thanks in advance for sharing!
Cheers!
The Wuss
And I also feel that this craft most often produces the "definitive version" of a given song.
Sometimes, though, a particular song might reach a new level of power and resonance in live performance. This might be the result of experimenting with a new musical arrangement (Clapton's unplugged Laya, for example), or a moment of cathartic performance, or even both.
A fine example, that I'd like to start with, is Fleetwood Mac's "Big Love".
The version on Tango in the Night is a fine song, and a fine album opener. But, when the song was performed live by Lindsey Buckingham (solo with guitar on The Dance DVD), it seemed to blossom into what I feel is the finest version of the song (and one of the more powerful live performances that I've seen in rock music).
Here's a Youtube video of the original version, followed by the live performance...
I'd love to hear what other people might point to, as great examples of songs that found their definitive voicing when performed live, rather than in the studio...
And I realize that there will be those among us who prefer live recordings in general. And also bands whose reputation as live performers might mean that their live albums are the "go to" document of their music (Phish, for example). But, I'd like to stay away from that subject matter, favoring those more "uncanny", singular live performances that transfixed us, and altered our perception of what the song could be...
Thanks for reading, and thanks in advance for sharing!
Cheers!
The Wuss