mrdon: Thanks so much for hosting the meet. I think it was a fantastic success.
It was really cool to meet a bunch of fellow Head-Fiers. Btw, if you awan to guaruntee an interesting meet, invite Hirsch! That's all I got to say.
taylor:
It seems the Qualia got beat up by a lot of folks. I keep on saying this but its hard to demo these without getting fitted, plan and simple. The Qualias
NEED to have a seal on your ears, they are built around this concept of forming a sealed chamber to create a magnificent soundstage (think 5000 detail but way bigger soundstage). The Qualias that were demoed were fitted for Hirsch - they barely fit me and as such sounded good and bad demanding on how I angled them. I say this because I've listened to them fitted for about 50 minutes and I still feel this is the most accurate dynamic headphone made on the planet. Of course YMMV as it seems these cans have had a love hate relantionship with the HeadFi community.
My quick initial impressions:
HE-90 Orpheus: Fantastic speed and soundstage. Everything was huge and it really attacks the music. Nothing phases it and there were no frequency rolloffs or dips across the spectrum. Accurate, fast, and big. Very impressive, but your wallet hurts.
ATH-L3000: One word, BASS. These cans do BASS very well, slightly boomy for me, but very nice indeed. They have a very smooth sound with a nice soundstage to them. We did a comparison with the Orpheus on the same track and I thought though the Orpheus had an even bigger soundstage, the L3000 had more bass or at least made the bass stand out more but wasn't as tight as the Orpheus.
R10: If you are a Senn man, this your headphone. To me, they were like the 600's but smoother, bigger, and more accurate. These are the type of cans you can listen to all day and not get fatigued. Vocals REALLY shine with these cans. They are naturally very tube like.
PS-1's: Ugggh, not for me. Yes, they do bass better but the Grado magic seems to have been totally removed out of these cans. I prefer the RS-1 sound completely.
AKG K1000: Yea, I get to hear them finally. Tons and tons of detail. Not enough bass. The bass is defined, tight, but not prominent when it should be in my opinion. What I really liked about this cans is their imaging (which can change by just postitioning the monitors on an angle).
SA5000's: Baby Qualias. As my friend said, "These are cold as ice like the Qualia's but lack teh soundstage." That's it in my opinion. You get a lot of what the Qualia offers for a fantastic price. To go back to my previous Qualia comment, because the 5000's are adjustable, you can get a clean fit with anyone's pair. Furthermore, by adjusting them incorrectly, they sound as bad the Qualia's do. Again, both cans rely on a tight fit. Anyway, I enjoyed these can's alot with the HeadRoom stuff. Very synergistic.
HeadRoom MAX Balanced: Not with Grados. Great with the Qualia's, 5000's (Desktop w/MAX module) and Senn's. I can see why HeadRoom prefers Senn's over Grado's. They just work better. What took the show (hopefully somebody will post pics) is how HUGE this amp is. I don't think the HeadRoom pics really do it justice on how much real estate this amp takes. HeadRoom amps are very fast in my opinion. Cans that need a fast reacting dynamic amp, really shine with HeadRoom.
Raptor: Lovely with my RS-1's, not so with the 5000's/Qualia's. Very nice with the L3000's, probably one of my favorite combos of the meet. Smooth, defined, and sweet. The Raptor is one of the few tube setups that I enjoyed.
The Hornet: A very nice portable amp. Small, battery powered, and seems to be able to drive any can you can think of (maybe minus the K1000). I thought the Hornet and HR-2 were very close with the HR-2 having a better slightly more pronounced bass. If you are in the portable amp market, you must demo the Hornet.
The theme throughout this meet was, "Damn, I really like the 600's over the 650's....", almost everyone who compared them side by side liked the 600's better. I many thought the 650's were slightly more accurate particularly in the mid range but more tonally recessed compared to the 650's. While I was driving home, my buddy said, the "600's or 650's would definitely sound better in the Carribean (Corona should consider talking to Sennheiser to feature the phones in the beer commercials!).
Anyway, again, I had a great time and really enjoyed meeting everyone.
Trogdor