A PM from another poster here asked if I would give him my thoughts on the Studio Reference 728 Silver and the Premium Ribbon HP Pure Silver Star 67 for the SR1a. I figured I might as well post it here as well. In each of the photos below the 728 is above and the Star 67 below. As can be seen the SR728 is 2 runs inside one sheath and the Star 67 looks like 2 runs wound around each other. I have no way of knowing what is under the sheaths but the Star 67 looks like a double run of SR 728. But, I could be wrong and the materials and metal specifics could be different in the two cables.
I’ve actually been focused on the “Deluxe” which RAAL states is a best match for the JOT R the past 2 weeks until this past weekend when I received my adapter to run the Susvara off my PrimaLuna EV 400.
I wasn’t expecting much difference between the SR 728 and Star 67 but maybe I’m wrong for the second time today, LOL!
Alternating the two cables on my HSA-1b (using the balanced inputs from Yggdrasil 2 and cd’s as source) while leaving the volume control set to the same number I was surprised by the difference as I rotated the two cables. One of the nice things I like about 4 pin XLR connectors at the amp end is I can plug and unplug at the amp end with a barely heard “click” where with ¼ inch connectors I’ve experienced some fairly exciting “pops”. I use XLR connectors whenever I can and it’s not about balance versus SE as the differences to me are slight between the two circuit designs, I just prefer the more substantial feel of those XLR barrels and nice quiet click that comes thru the phones when I plug and unplug at the amp end. And I always disconnect from the amp before unplugging at the HP’s, we don’t want a possible short now do we?
Using my usual suspect Chesky, Sheffield, and Decca recordings:
What I heard was the SR 728 as a bit punchier, immediate and maybe more dynamic but the soundfield was not as deep as with the Star 67.
Both seemed equally wide. Imaging was the same.
The Star 67 was smoother and more laid back with better depth.
The SR 728 was a bolder sound, the Star 67 more relaxed.
There is one possible caveat; the milder sound of the Star 67 didn’t jump out as much giving the impression that the volume level was a hair lower than with the SR 728. I’m frying too many other fish at this time and will put the sound level meter to this thought when the VM-1a releases and I may pick up another SR1a and put both cables to the meter test to see if there is a volume level for given input level difference.
Also, I often feel that raising the volume level has a tendency to bring the musicians in closer to me and reduces the depth of the soundfield. Lowering the volume seems to do the opposite. That’s why I feel it is necessary to maintain equal volume levels when evaluating two components and I do consider cabling a part of the component chain especially with the SR1a and its 0.01 ohm impedance of the ribbons which requires the cable to be the load sufficient enough to keep the amp from shutting down or worse.
Both cables sound very good with the SR1a /HSA-1b combo and are much preferred by me over the stock cable it came with.
Is one better than the other? I don’t think so, their just different and it will be up to each listener who wants just one accessory cable to decide. I suspect more popular music genres which generally seem to be studio recordings will be fun with the SR 728 and large scale symphonic or chamber might work well with the Star 67 (or with both). And I note again I’ve spent more time with the “Deluxe” cable and the JOT R recently but have been using the SR 728 on both amps since that model was released.
Price-wise these cables are identical, and in the higher priced cable manufacturing sweepstakes competition these seem reasonably fair.
One final thought. Varying amounts of inductance, capacitance, and resistance of the respective cables might be the reasons for the difference in sound I hear. And the SR1a is very good at displaying differences. Time will tell me. Anyway, that’s my take on these two as of today. I don’t think you can go wrong either way.