Got my Sonica today!
Using it in a "traditional " headphones setup with a headphones amp. "Feeding" music via Roon and microRendu as a endpoint (on USB input). Network is disabled on Oppo.
Question:
Do you guys choose "bypass all", and control volume through the Amp?
That's how I've been using mine, in "Bypass All Input" mode, with the outputs feeding my HA-1. XLR outputs going into HA-1 XLR in. I have both units connected to USB Async port, however, so I can compare both units simultaneously to playback coming out of my MacMini.
Got mine this past Saturday and for the most part, it's nice, but I'm not convinced that I'll keep it, not because it isn't a great sounding unit, it is, very much so, but in my system, it's really a redundant device that doesn't make a whole lot of sense for me to keep but the jury is still out on that, so we'll see.
Lately I've been primarily listening to Tidal HiFI as my main music source so I've been able to compare the built in Tidal stream of the Sonica to both the desktop version through the USB port from my Mac and also the desktop version feeding into my HA-1 and in addition to that I have an Oppo BDP 105 w/ the built in Tidal app of it feeding to my HA-1, so I can actually compare al 3 units through balanced output with my PM-1's (and other HP's)
There is so much similarity (to me) in the sound between the 3 devices that it's nearly impossible to tell a difference if I were to do an A/B/C blind test. They all sound fantastic to me. No Sabre glare, no harsh highs, just satisfying mids, deep bass, and smooth mids. I know that others have their own opinions about the ESS sound, but to me it's very pleasing. I think a lot of that has to do with the smoothness of the PM-1's. If there is any winner in sound, I suppose it would an ever so slight edge to the Sonica DAC in sound stage and separation, but it's in no way a large advantage, just slight.
The main drawback for me against the Sonica DAC is not the sound but the lack of a physical remote control. I know, I know, it has the app that pretty much controls the device completely but in this age of high end electronics, it just makes no sense at all to me to not include a remote. My HA-1 has a remote that works beautifully and I've even mapped it's functions into my Harmony remote and of course the BDP 105 has a remote as well and is a more capable all-around player.
Would I recommend the Sonica to potential buyers? Well, maybe. It depends on your needs. If you need an outstanding, well built, stand alone streaming player that can be networked for local playback and has Airplay, Bluetooth and multiple digital inputs then absolutely I would recommend. It sounds fantastic and would make a great addition to most buyers racks. If you're like me and already have multiple, similar devices that already have most or all of the features that you'd get from the Sonica and are happy with the sound that they are producing now, then I would say, think long and hard before making your decision. You could do like I've done and give it a test spin for 30 days before making your ultimate decision to keep or not, (my decision is not concrete yet but I think I already know which way I'm leaning).
I'm gonna continue to play with it in the weeks to come, as well as try some other configurations, like connecting to my floor standing speakers through an Emotiva amp and do more comparisons with my other devices for more listening test and I'll see how it stacks up while playing 2 channel music.
I'll keep you guys posted.