Quote:
May I ask what headphone amplifier did you use to compare for your non-stat headphones?
Also, between headphones and speakers, which of the 2 provide a higher resolution now that you've spent sufficient time listening to a top tier headphone setup? - even when given that speakers suffer from a disadvantage due to room acoustics.
I'm curious to know because I've been wanting to purchase a speaker that's even more revealing than my current headphone and for all the other obvious reasons.
The frequency response chart of your speakers is impressive and measure exceptionally well but obviously didn't satisfy you enough judging from your purchase of the o2's - which itself together with its amp sells for as much as your studio monitors.
I personally own a respectable speaker setup which costed me £3000/$4500 and find room acoustics to be minimal unless I turn the volume knob really high up, when it does affect the overall sound, I find that it's mostly the bass reacting to my non-treated room.
I sit 2 metres away which might explain why.
I'm just using standard pro audio gear for dynamic headphones. I've auditioned expensive amps in the past and didn't find them all that much better, while all costing more than a grand. Headphone amps are perhaps some of the most overrated and hyped piece of gear in the audio chain, and most aren't all that much better than the headphone outs of cheap pro audio gear.
Between headphones and speakers, it's really up to which headphones and which speakers you are comparing. I mean, if you are comparing a flagship Stax rig or a LCD-2 or even a HD650 with entry level M-Audio monitor speakers, then there's no comparison because the entry level M-Audio monitors are just grating on the nerves. But if we're talking about the same headphones going up against my Klein + Hummel O 300D's (retails close to $7,000 a pair, and costs more than twice as much as my Stax 007mk2 and 717), then it's a very different story. The O 300D's definitely kick all the headphones asses--IF you can provide the right acoustic environment for them. This is even taking into consideration that after extensive acoustic treatment and room correction with the ARC System, there are still some nulls I can't get rid of. The dimensionality, visceral impact, and vivid lushness of the O 300D's in my studio really is far superior and much more satisfying. The nulls I have are pretty narrow band so they don't really call attention to themselves when listening to musical material--it's only when I do grueling technical tests like log sweeps that I notice them. With the ARC System engaged and additional EQ'ing to further flatten the frequency response, my O 300D's really blow me away in my studio. I do plenty of A/B comparisons between my headphones and the O 300D's, including trying to get the headphones to match the speakers with crossfeed and room sims, but it's just not the same.
While it's true that great headphones can be very good and there's no room mode to deal with, they will never be as dimensional, visceral, or satisfying as a pair of high-end full-range speakers. It's more than just the low frequency vibrations--it's simply that with speakers sound travels through the air and that interaction with the air molecules and the acoustic space does something that we don't experience with headphones. For critical audio work, headphones are just fine if I use crossfeed/room sims, but for a satisfying musical experience, I definitely prefer my O 300D's. If I had a room-in-a-room constructed studio where I could blast the O 300D's during any hour and no one will hear it, then I probably wouldn't ever listen to headphones again except for when I'm tracking. But I didn't have the necessary space to construct my studio to eliminate structural noise, so I must use headphones in some situations.
Truth is, if I wasn't using kickass monitors like the O 300D, I probably wouldn't have been so demanding in my choice of headphones--I'd probably have been happy with my old HD555 or settled on the HD650 and called it quits. It was because I wanted to find headphones that could match my O 300D's that I escalated my headphones budget and journey, and at this point, the headphones still aren't quite there, but they are already very good so I'm fine taking a break from chasing the diminishing returns for now.