I am testing a closed headphones setup for my lovely new open-space work cubicle.
For phones I have my trusty Ety 4Ps, but will primarily use newly purchased Focal Spirit Pro, which provides much of the clarity and separation of the 4Ps but with more bass and a speaker-like presentation.
Testing these phones with Meridian Explorer this morning...I actually agree with several of the OP's conclusions (excessive ranting aside). While there is no doubt that Explorer is a quality audio product, it does have a "warm and silky" sound profile. Is that good? Well, on the one hand, it kind of works well with the 4Ps by somewhat taming their overly-analytical quality. But with the Spirit Pros, I didn't like how it soothed away subtle harmonics in the upper midrange. So to me, it DID color the sound at the expense of smoothness.
I expected it to be levels above the iBassoCobra D10 I already have. It does bring out more fullness and instrument seperation than the D10, but not $300 worth. I'll go through the threads later, but if anybody has a suggestion for a worthy portable DAC upgrade they think lines up with my stated sound preferences, I would love to hear about it!
Thanks, -Max