Sonic Defender
Headphoneus Supremus
WOW it is amazing how the opinions of these differ. I had them returned them and had them again because I thought I wasn't being fair and returned them again. I will however say they are the best Beats I have heard, not sure what that means.
Not that a headphone being very genre specific is a good trait, but perhaps what styles of music you both listen to are different enough that for one it was good, for the other bad? I'm thinking how on say the Grado house sound (sharp pronounced highs, forward mids, less bass extension) somebody who liked electronica may find the signature unpleasant, but somebody who listens to soft or vocal jazz that is well mastered may like the signature.