I tried in the last days the optical and USB and for me they do not sound in the same way. But first to explain the environment:
1) source 1 is a PC with Foobar and ASIO where I play FLAC files, connected to Qutest via a 3m QED Reference USB A-B cable
2) source 2 is a CXC (CD transport), connected to Qutest via a 1m QED Reference Quartz optical cable
Both inputs are connected at the same time, and I switch the input via the button. Qutest is connected via RCA to a tube Amp.
I tried the same CD in the CXC from which I encoded the FLAC files. So we have the same album, the same DAC and the same AMP and I use the same headphones (T1.2).
Normally, we would expect to have minimal differences, and almost the same sound on both, right? But for me the optical input sounds darker than the USB. And the difference is not subtle.
So I guess the only difference can be the jitter on USB, since the optical has to be "isolated" from the electrical interference.
Other factor might be that the PC is plugged in a normal power outlet while the CXC is plugged (alongside the tube amp) in a Furman power conditioner which has to provide a better AC filtering than for the PC.
If I am wrong in my assumptions please correct me. Anyone tried such an 1:1 test with COAX?
It’s not the jitter on the USB for 2 reasons. One, the USB timing is asynchronous, meaning the timing comes from the DAC so there should be zero jitter. Two, Rob’s designs are jitter immune on all inputs due to the Pulse Array design. Likely you are hearing the difference from RF noise being injected in to the analogue components with USB making it sound brighter. As you rightly mentioned the optical is electrically isolated so does not transmit the RF noise so this is the most likely reason why it sounds darker, as Rob has explained many times.
I think it is some type of noise because my high power pc gives sibilance with usb but none when using optical