You're way oversimplifying things. If you think that measurements that say flat tuning = real sound for all genres , than enjoy. Plenty of people don't like the Harman target (or any target really). Everyone has different hearing and it also varies with age for the same person. Even sitting in a different position at a venue sounds different.Well the difference between your preferences and mine is probably that I rarely, if ever, listen to the type of music and recordings you seem to prefer.
I just came back from the second live concert this month with live acoustic unamplified instruments and the human voice in real acoustic venues and THAT is my reference point.
I did NOT find any instrument or voices sounding "too neutral".
A bit different in loudness depending on where I listened from in the halls. But always sounding like real instruments .
As a photographer I am used to changing perspectives.
I want my HIFI systems both via headphones and more often than via headphones via my speaker based system to replicate as closely as possible the real timbre and sound of acoustic intruments in a real venue, not a warmed raised treble or boomy bass lifted or otherwise unnaturally coloured version.
Transparency and neutrality are the goals I strive for and if my memory serves me right again,it normally does, only a few days ago that the designer of Dave and other Chord dacs once again mentioned those same goals as his too.
Each to his own ....
Cheers CC
The reality is that there are a ton of variables ,not to mention mastering . If you have a neutral chain you can get different headphones better suited to different genres of music. In a chase for realism. No one is looking for unnatural sound, you won't find many flagships that target that.
However if you get a colored chain, you can't "fix the coloration" for different genres with the headphones/speakers and it gets much harder to get that synergy which results in a "real" sound. That's also something Rob was saying.
It's like trying to paint over a blue canvas instead of a white one.