Ruben123
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- May 17, 2012
- Posts
- 1,849
- Likes
- 267
Hello all,
I think the discussion about IEMs vs open backed IEMs (such as ADEL, but also cheap IEMs like KZ HDS1 [$6]) vs earbuds is interesting and of highly importance, with the growing use of music on the go and hearing damage of the youth.
Ive come across several points of view, of whichI think could only 1 be scientifically correct. For instance, SPL should be less in non isolating earphones (such as open backed IEMs or earbuds) vs IEMs on the same subjective volume. This seems to be correct, but
There is a but. I almost freaked out yesterday when connecting my earbuds to my media player set to line out (+2 dB), my ears bled for a second. Measuring the SPL of it, which came to my surprise, was about 75dB. When connecting a normal IEM to the same player, set to about -10 dB volume, I measured 78 dB.
Now before going into detail, my normal listening volume with the earbuds AND IEMs is around -32 dB on this player. This means that for the same SPL the volume needed to be raised much higher for the earbuds, although at around -32dB, they both seem about as loud as the other (because I generally listen to -32dB). With those ADEL, for instance, earphones on the market, claiming less outputted decibels at the same "hearing level", I think this is an interesting discussion. How can the outputted volume seem to high even though the measured ¨volume" was quite low?
So, there is more to hearing damage than only SPL.I think.
Ive also read that IEMs create a high pressure in the middle ear, which, even with low volume, could create hearing damage. In that light one would need open-backed IEMs or earbuds, but Im not convinced. Enough about me.
Hereby Id like to open this thread for a central discussion.Not about my experience, that was only an introduction to the subject lol
I think the discussion about IEMs vs open backed IEMs (such as ADEL, but also cheap IEMs like KZ HDS1 [$6]) vs earbuds is interesting and of highly importance, with the growing use of music on the go and hearing damage of the youth.
Ive come across several points of view, of whichI think could only 1 be scientifically correct. For instance, SPL should be less in non isolating earphones (such as open backed IEMs or earbuds) vs IEMs on the same subjective volume. This seems to be correct, but
There is a but. I almost freaked out yesterday when connecting my earbuds to my media player set to line out (+2 dB), my ears bled for a second. Measuring the SPL of it, which came to my surprise, was about 75dB. When connecting a normal IEM to the same player, set to about -10 dB volume, I measured 78 dB.
Now before going into detail, my normal listening volume with the earbuds AND IEMs is around -32 dB on this player. This means that for the same SPL the volume needed to be raised much higher for the earbuds, although at around -32dB, they both seem about as loud as the other (because I generally listen to -32dB). With those ADEL, for instance, earphones on the market, claiming less outputted decibels at the same "hearing level", I think this is an interesting discussion. How can the outputted volume seem to high even though the measured ¨volume" was quite low?
So, there is more to hearing damage than only SPL.I think.
Ive also read that IEMs create a high pressure in the middle ear, which, even with low volume, could create hearing damage. In that light one would need open-backed IEMs or earbuds, but Im not convinced. Enough about me.
Hereby Id like to open this thread for a central discussion.Not about my experience, that was only an introduction to the subject lol