exhale
100+ Head-Fier
- Joined
- Feb 6, 2016
- Posts
- 111
- Likes
- 207
Well, i guess it just wasn't meant to be. Sadly, i cannot go through my usual ~1 week of solo listening only to the new pair of headphones simply because the way they're tuned makes my tinnitus shout "Stop it, i'm dead already!!". Sigh.Just got these today (mainly, because everyone seems to hate them and since "everyone" generally includes treble happy, bass shy "audiophiles" i thought they might just be for me).
Will come back after a few days with the listening impressions (just to be clear, no burn-in on my side, just simple listening since day 1) but as far as initial impressions go, these are everything that the LCD-2s failed to be and then some. One small complaint is that mine, although bought new, came with some minor scuffs on the ear cups, exactly where they meet with the ear pads and it made me think that either someone tried to swap the ear pads or they came like this straight from Beyer (which would be a shame). Waiting on the retailer to see how can this be sorted without the lengthy return / resend.
Here go my (very brief) impressions with the Beyerdynamic T1 3rd gen. First of all, i LOVE their sound. From the first second i've put them on, i thought (as i wrote in the quoted post) that they are everything the LCD-2 were supposed to be. Well, i was both right and wrong. I chose to compare them to the LCD-2 because that's the pair i'm currently looking a replacement for and honestly, comparing them to some of my other headphones would simply be unfair (Arya SE, HD800S, IE 900).
They have bass. This is an understatement since it seems like all the bass in the world has gathered and decided "You know what? We're all gonna go inside the T1.3's drivers". So much bass that, sadly, it leaks into the midrange and this is what destroys my ears by making them ring like a school bell on a lunch break.
They got good towards great headstage with good (not great) instrument separation. They are devoid of a proper midrange and while this might not be a bad thing (basically, an intended V-shape(ish) sound signature), the bass leakage ruins some songs while others, it makes them more pleasant. I also have a pair of Amirons around and chose to compare these 2 together. They are very much alike, with the treble spike more present on the Amirons and with extra bass on the T1.
I usually have a rotating playlist of a babel tower sorts of songs. I start with Infected Mushroom's Deeply Disturbed and carry on with a few tracks from Enigma. Then, i switch to some 90's pop and rock (Leonard Cohen, Madonna's Ray of Light album, etc.). After that, i go down the chill route and play some Vangelis, Zimmer and Two Steps from Hell. Further on, i switch to Astrix, Ranji, Vini Vici and Juno Reactor so get my blood pumping and i keep it there with tracks from Airbase, Leon Bolier, Hiver & Hammer, etc. In total, i'm talking about 40-50 songs which i rotate, based on mood, mostly, at around 3-4 months. Out of all these songs, i could barely listen and enjoy to 8-10 of them. And these are comprised almost entirely out of pure progressive tracks (which are bass heavy, light on the mids and sprinkled with high freqs due to the usual effects used in the genre). I never had a pair of headphones ring my ears while listening to Madonna's The Power of Goodbye or Gregorian's Join Me. Ever. Unless i really pumped up the volume (which shouldn't even matter since this might be the case for every headphone out there).
I normally stay away from any other headphone when i buy a new pair, just to make sure that i get accustomed, properly, to its new sound signature and be able to appreciate it at its full value. Today, after ~3 hours of playback, my left inner-ear started hurting and i had to stop and swap them for my Arya SE just to see if the same song (in this case, Gregorian's Join Me) would make my ears ring. Not even close. Perfect rendition of the track, exactly as i knew and heard on multiple other pairs of both headphones and iems.
I'm gonna touch a bit on its bass, since it seems to be the T1s forte. It's a lot of bass so from a quantity point of view, it has more than probably any other headphone i have ever listened to (besides the MDR Z7 but a few good years have passed since i have listened to those). From a quality point of view, i tried comparing it to that of the Arya and the IE 900 (i know, it's apples to oranges since these are IEMs but at the end of the day, they both have the same job - blow sound towards and inside my ears). Different sorts of emphasis on these: the T1s, while not lacking sub bass, have a clear mid-bass emphasis while the Arya and IE 900 have both a very clean, powerful and distinct sub bass with the IE 900 being my personal favorite, as far as this goes.
I found the highs muted, in some way. It didn't bother me and as i wrote, i wanted them to be a complimentary pair of headphones so i wasn't looking for huge soundstage and clarity. Still, some sounds in some of the songs i listen to, for over 15 years, in some cases, were either missing or barely present and noticeable.
Alas, i could have overlooked everything about these, since i really wanted to love them at least as much as i have loved the Amiron Home (which i haven't used for 2-3 years, Jesus!) but it seems this was a very short honeymoon. I understood perfectly what others love about the T1.3 and i, too, would have felt the same but unfortunately, they didn't check too many points on my list. As a final conclusion: they are incredibly high quality made headphones with a lot of bass which, depending on the recording, can be either a blessing or a curse; they have surprisingly good headstage with a decent instrument separation but the bass leaking into the otherwise absent mids makes them less than perfect for accurate reproduction of bass-heavy songs (trance, progressive, psy/goa, etc.). The package is a bit lacking, for a 1000$ headphone and sadly, it does not make up for it through sound quality. Personally, i will find it hard to recommend them to anyone else besides bass heads and casual listeners and as far as their retail price is concerned, i think they would fit better in the 5-700$ category (as RRP, not discounted price).
P.S. These are my own, personal impressions of the Beyerdynamic T1 3rd gen. I, as all of you out there, have personal preferences when it comes to sound and although i consider myself a very versatile listener, i still drift toward certain genres which make my choices easier. Your mileage might vary.