ATH-AD900 Score = 9.2
http://headphones.reviewed.com/content/audio-technica-ath-ad900-review
Introduction:
"Their performance is fantastic, and they are extremely comfortable, but their use is highly specialized: at home."
Audio Quality:
"After we ran the ATH-AD900s through our tests in the lab a few times, we've concluded that they have extremely good audio performance. Throughout every test we ran, we noticed that they had very few if any appreciable blemishes in their performance, and across the board they took top marks."
Conclusion:
"Overall, the Audio-Technica ATH-AD900s are fantastic performers for their price range, with the added benefit of being super comfortable, and a low power requirement."
Science Introduction:
"These cans have got the goods, and knocked it out of the park in many aspects of our scoring. Not only do they have a flat frequency response, but they have a very low distortion measure, and passable tracking."
------------
ATH-AD900X Score = 8.3
http://headphones.reviewed.com/content/audio-technica-ath-ad900x
Introduction:
"Although it carries a very similar name to its predecessor, the
Audio-Technica ATH-AD900, its performance is quite a bit different in terms of frequency response. While it's more of a taste thing at its core, these cans look the part, but don't exactly deliver the same quality sound that the series is known for."
Sound Quality:
"...where the ATH-AD900 reproduced most sounds at the same volume more or less, the ATH-AD900x does not—some of the more sibilant sounds like cymbals and the highest octave of a piano will be reduced in perceived loudness by about half."
Conclusion:
"Just keep in mind that these headphones mark a slight departure from the previous iteration, as they do not have a completely even frequency response—they underemphasize some of the higher sounds, and that may or may not fit with what you're looking for."
--------------
Click "Science and Testing" in the upper right corner of the review to see graphs for each model.
Frequency Response:
It appears that the grey lines on the AD900X graph are to compare to the AD900
"The most important thing to note about the performance is the lack of a completely flat frequency response. This will appeal to some who find really high notes and resonances to be painful in loud music, but maybe not so much to users who demand all sounds to be at the same volume as others. You can easily equalize these underemphases away, but it does require a bit of work on your end."
---------------
This reviewer certainly seems to prefer the older model, AD900.