Folks, there isn't an engineering reason why EtherRegen could make any difference. Save your moneys for things you really need...
Okay, I think I know where this is going, and I would normally not even offer any kind of response, because debates such as thIs always risk bringing on one of my least favorite aspects of this hobby... The said "aspects" are debates that start off as if they are discussions about "science," but often turn out to be really about either subjective preferences that cannot be proven, at best (because they have nothing to do with science), or, at worst, about prejudices butting heads in futility. In futility as they cannot be proven by any scientific evidence, for the simple reason that there are several aspects of our hobby, especially, those in the area of rules governing the relationship between scientific measurements, tastes, preferences, and even sensory perceptions, that cannot be explained by any science that is available.
Such debates often begin in disagreements, and more often than not, end in unresolved stalemates, sometimes very acrimonious stalemates, not necessarily because one of the parties is more "correct" than the other, but because they have engaged on a path that is doomed to end in a cul de sac, and the participants do not know how to agree to disagree before they end up in that cul de Sac. This pattern is unfortunately quite familiar, tired, and old, in this hobby, and I am sure everyone or most people have seen or even experienced it at least once in audiophile discussions, if not 10 times or even more. I personally do not find it either entertaining or too productive, so I am definitely not trying to have one now, although I shall try to respond to your statement once, as nicely and politely as I can, for reasons of human camaraderie, forum goodwill, and friendship
, and then hope we can put this behind us, even if we happen to disagree, before this devolves into another one of those stalemate scenarios I just mentioned.
So here goes:
1. I am no engineer, so I cannot take any scientifically informed position about your statement regarding engineering reasons and the 'etherregen, which does not mean I am buying the statement either, but even if it were true, it still wouldn't make any difference to me, because I do not think engineering has the authority to explain many aspects of this hobby that we enjoy, and why we enjoy them or not. For example, there are no engineering reasons why some types of music or sounds move me to tears, while others fill me with warm and fuzzy feelings, while others yet simply annoy me or leave me cold... Yet such a lack of engineering reasons will not stop me from seeking and listening to the music that sounds pleasing to my ears, so why should anything be different about the etherregen, if it enhances the enjoyment of the music I listen to...? You see where I am going with this...?
2. On another note, a lot of audio experts and insiders have already said it, so I shall take it for granted that this is sufficiently well-known info, and not belabor it too much : There is a lot about what we hear in music, sounds effects, and their relationship to our senses of appreciation that engineering reasons cannot account for, even while it takes great and well-honed engineering skills to make the best AV gear currently available on the market. One simple case in point is the relationship between measurements and sound quality, or in other words, the fact that the equipment that measure best do not necessarily sound the best, and that there are actually equipment that measure very well that positively sound soulless and plain awful! Again this issue is well known, and I see no need to argue it with any length...
3.More seriously, and in case you think I am taking the demand for engineering reasons too lightly, the reason why I cannot take what you have said at face value, lies in my own trust in the work of John Swenson, who is the brains behind the etherregen. He himself has been researching this science for decades, and has a wealth of scientific and engineering reasons to explain the kind of work the etherregen does, and why it makes the difference it makes Again I am no engineer, but I know John Swenson is a person of integrity, and not just a very smart electrical engineer... I have taken some free expert advice from him and applied them to my home audio system, and the results have been immediately palpable and overwhelmingly positive, So we do have a history, albeit a small one, and at this point I feel a lot more comfortable and confident than not, about accepting his word and his engineering reasons about the etherregen and how it works, and that is why I have opted to purchase one in the first place,
Incidentally my own unit arrives next month, so I have not experienced it myself yet... However, there are others on Audiophile style whose judgment I trust from experience, who have more sophisticated rigs than mine, and who have reported overwhelmingly positive results in using the Etherregen, and at this point, I see no good reason to doubt their positive impressions, In fact they have only confirmed my confidence and the level of comfort with which I have embraced the etherregen, and I am sure I am going to enjoy it. In the very unlikely chance that I do not enjoy it, I would simply resell it on the market, and that would be very easy since the etherregen is extremely popular among its own niche of enthusiasts at the moment.
Incidentally, this rant has turned out to be waaaay longer than I planned. That is okay, but I'd prefer not to have a long futile etherregen-related debate, since it would be off topic to start with, and second, since it is not likely to get us anywhere interesting under these circumstances,
Thanks for your attention !