Here's my Song by Song Break Down
The Ultimate Headphone Demonstration Disc (Dr. Chesky) #16 Four Surround Voices
For this track, I found my NFB10ES2 to perform the best, presenting each voice exactly as it states it self. The left rear voice is a bit close, and on each of the other units it sounded... to the left but not quite behind my ear, only the NFB10ES2 presented that voice behind me. So really, the JDS Labs was on par with my Hifiman HM 901 with this track.
Kind of Blue (2015 Mobile Sound Fidelity Labs Re-release) [Miles Davis] #01 So What
Frankly, this was one of my favorite tracks to listen to with The Element, I'm used to a very hard presentation and powerful presentation with my NFB10ES2 and my Hm 901, the Element was able to present the same level of detail as those two, without sounding as hard. It had a much more relxaed sound. While the HM 601 had more consistantly pleasent tone and a more powerful low end, it did not carry as much detail as The Element did. Even running the HM 601 into my iBasso PB2, I still found my self going back to The Element.
How ever, while a touch hard, I did find that only the HM 901 and NFB10ES2 presented me with the most realsitc sense of sustain. Both the sax and trumpet, wail a little as they hold some of the longer notes, this beautiful detail was not easily grasaple with The Element or my Hm 601. Though to be fair, both the NFB10ES2 and HM 901 were in much higher price categories.
Igor Levit: Bach, Beethoven, Rzewski #01 Goldberg Variations, BWV 988 - Aria with 30 Variations
Frankly, while it kept up with the detail of the NFB10ES2 and the HM 901, The Element did not present proper timbre for me in this track. The low notes on the paino were too soft, the higher registers were too hard, almost shouty and everything in the middle was really wet. Detail, was again very good, but I preffered even my HM 601 to The Element for this track in particular.
The Ultimate Headphone Demonstration Disc (Dr. Chesky) #20 Drum and Bell: Walk Around Mic
The Element was really fun here, just like the NFB10ES2 and HM901 I got to listen to both instruments walk slowly around the mic. Best of all, I found the tone of the drum to be best on The Element. Both the Hm901 and NFB10ES2 presented it sounding... almost too hollow, where as The Element had a nice soft warmth in addition to a disintclly hollow sound. My only gripe is with the bell, it was... just too metallaic at times on The Element. Though that slight tinge of over emphasis, did help the finer details of the bell pop out again'st the warmth of the drum.
The Ultimate Headphone Demonstration Disc (Dr. Chesky) #24 Height Center Shaker
The Element, easily presented me with changes in height up top, but not depth or anything moving beneath your preceieved center. The shaker comes up from the bottom, and I didn't get that.... sense of up from below and up above with The Element. While the shaker was below the mic, The Element presented it as if it were... in front of you not so much as underneath. It did better than the HM 601 and UCA 202, but it wasn't quite on par with the HM 901 or NFB10ES2.
The Ultimate Headphone Demonstration Disc (Dr. Chesky) #26 Height Left Channel Shaker
The Element, did really well here with changes in height up top, but not depth or anything moving beneath your preceieved center. The shaker comes up from the bottom, and I didn't get that.... sense of up from below and up above with The Element. While the shaker was below the mic, The Element presented it as if it were... in front of you not so much as under neath. Both the HM901 and NFB10ES2 had a very real sense of below, the shaker really sounds like it's COMING for you with those, as it creeps up from below accompanied by gentle foot steps. While listening on the Hm 901 and NFB10ES2, If you closed your eye's it was kinda scary, as you could hear and feel the shaker next to your ear. The sounds was much softer on The Element. The Hm 601 and Behnring UCA 202, also had this odd out in front as opposed to below sound, and each of those were also quite bad moving above you, as well as from beneath.
The Ultimate Headphone Demonstration Disc (Dr. Chesky) #28 Height Right Channel Shaker
The right shaker track, is different from the left. What's cool is there is this obnixous echo throughout the entire track, you can hear it on both left and right channels. Neither The Element nor the UCA 202 presented clear changes to the sutatined sound of the echo. Rather, starting with the HM 601 that sustained echo got little quiter and a little louder as the shaker... shook. There were also, audilbe foot steps, the sound of some one walking up something, these foot steps were most apparent on The Element, the NFB 10ES2 and HM 901 presented them a little further back from you. As opposed to the more in your face presentation on The Element, interestingly enough you couldn't quite perceive the foot steps on the HM 601 or UCA 202.
Finally, what I really liked about The Element's softer more forward bass, is things like... a humm are very audible. There was in fact, this really odd 50/60hrz hum in this track, only The Element presented that detail natrually the Magnum V7 Black Lime/Maple Sleeved Dynamic. After I noticed it, I could in fact hear it through the HM 901 and NFB10ES2 but I had to look for it! Only jumping up to my HE 4 on my NFB10ES2 gave me that same... natural presentation of such a subtle detail.
As a side note, this was not any kind of equipment introduced hum. My Spectograph did read a very low output, starting at 45 and upwards of 60 hrz, it almost sounded like an Air Conditioner running in the back ground.
The Ultimate Headphone Demonstration Disc (Dr. Chesky) #53 Heart Beat Tracks
The best way I can describe how each Amp/Dac sounded with these Heart Beat tracks is onomatopoeia...
- The NFB 10ES2 goes Ka thUD ka thUD ka thUDD ka thUDD, not quite as much attack as hm901, but more texture. Offers no help with the roll off, but maintains it's texture even with a poor sub bass response.
- The Element...It’s diffuse, doesn’t have the POWER and clarity of the HM 901 or NFB10ES2, the transition from 40-50 is not as apparent, but diffuse low end does help with the gentle sub bass roll off on the Magnum V7 Dynamic.
- The HM 601 has a nice heavy low end, it's got the power but not the texture... and a poor transition from 40-50, keeps good power down into 20 Hrz and also helps with the Gentle Sub Bass Roll off on the Magun V7 Dynamic.
- The HM 901 goes Ka ThuD ka THUD Ka THUDD Ka THUDDD Ka THUDD, more power in sub bass, but not as much texture. Offers no help with the roll off, but maintains it's power even with a poor sub bass response.
All in all, I hope you guys find my musing helpful. I do wish I had another mid range Dac/Amp to compare with. Still out of my UCA 202 and my HM 601, The Element did an outstanding job!