souperman
Headphoneus Supremus
- Joined
- Feb 8, 2007
- Posts
- 2,971
- Likes
- 10
Would SPDIF out of a stand-alone sound card be better than out of my onboard sound (Realtek Audio)?
Originally Posted by souperman /img/forum/go_quote.gif Would SPDIF out of a stand-alone sound card be better than out of my onboard sound (Realtek Audio)? |
Originally Posted by pincellone /img/forum/go_quote.gif I believe this is strictly hardware dependent. As there are plenty of differences among pc motherboards with integrated audio and soundcards, if you manage to get a spare soundcard try yourself. Don't forget to disable all the software bells and whistles and enable SPDIF digital out... If possible install an ASIO driver as well and choos a reliable player such as Winamp or Foobar. In my opinion ANY soundcard will affect audio quality anyway, so the quest for the bitperfect signal should consider this limitation. Anyway, this soundcard should do the job nicely and it's quite cheap: Chaintech AV710 Reviews |
Originally Posted by souperman /img/forum/go_quote.gif Just wondering why a different sound card's will have different digital out. To my limited understanding, it's just digital being outputed, so why would the 1's and 0's be different? Sorry I'm still quite new to this. Does the onboard sound chip quality matter if using SPDIF? - Yahoo! Answers That is where I got my idea about digital. |
Originally Posted by souperman /img/forum/go_quote.gif Just wondering why a different sound card's will have different digital out. To my limited understanding, it's just digital being outputed, so why would the 1's and 0's be different? Sorry I'm still quite new to this. Does the onboard sound chip quality matter if using SPDIF? - Yahoo! Answers That is where I got my idea about digital. |
Originally Posted by pincellone /img/forum/go_quote.gif Yes, they are 0s and 1s but sometimes the sequence of these numbers (final digital output) might be different. Otherwise ANY soundcard would perform the very same job when passing data to a DAC. In my experience this is not the case. Anybody else on this topic? |
Originally Posted by shinew /img/forum/go_quote.gif It is because of the jitter. I'm sticking with USB capable DAC. This is a good read -> nugent |
Originally Posted by Penchum /img/forum/go_quote.gif I can only give an opinion on this topic. I have read thousands of posts here and elsewhere about it, and they have not provided a solid foundation to call them a FACT. There are experts on both sides of this thing, and this does nothing but strengthen my opinion. I am not on either side of this. While "Jitter" exists, it doesn't appear to be audible in 99.9% of audio at our level. Many wish to prevent it and spend money to prevent it, but they have never heard it. Many don't do anything about it, and they have never heard it either. Some push it like it was the most terrible thing that can happen to digital audio, but they haven't heard it either. A few claim to have heard it, but not in their system, so it is someone else's problem. Knowing that audio problems can pile up, where one doesn't matter much, but many, one on top of the other, can create a situation that is audible, makes this issue very easy to deal with. Assume you don't have it. Get your system together, break it in, and enjoy the music. If you have an issue, you will hear it. If you don't hear it, then don't worry about it. Enjoy the music. A great deal of time and effort is spent on "what if" situations around here and I believe that time and effort is better spent on "what is" and enjoying the music. Just my 2 cents. |
Originally Posted by oatmeal769 /img/forum/go_quote.gif I think this is a good answer about jitter as well. Nothing to worry about until LOTS of other stuff is fixed first. I think there's more concern to be had about getting the untouched file through the operating system and audio software and into the DAC. This I believe is audible. Making no changes other than operating system (XP vs. VISTA) I can hear differences on nothing but my Sony reciever with my Senn's. From what I've read lately, a USB to TOSlink/Coax conversion running into an outboard DAC is the best way to do it. This means bypassing the soundcard completely. What remains unclear to me is whether the file is untouched as it proceeds through the player, windows, hardware, etc. as it is converted to an optical or coaxial signal. Some seem to think my cheap Behringer 202 is fine, others seem to think other software and better USB converters are needed. P.S., To stay on topic, My ZERO DAC should be here today!! |
Originally Posted by Penchum /img/forum/go_quote.gif While I agree that the USB to TOSlink/Coaxial to outboard DAC is the "handiest" thing to do, I'm not entirely sold on the idea that USB should be bought and used instead of a built-in digital out. Most of the lower cost USB converters are USB 1.0 or 1.1, and there can be issues with the USB line getting too busy. I suppose if someone tried their built-in digital out and can't get it to behave, then the USB option would be worth spending additional monies on. |
Originally Posted by Penchum /img/forum/go_quote.gif *NOTE* I have an update for all Zero users. Thanks to other Zero users, the true "pre-amp" function (a volume controlled output feature) has been found. If you press the button for Phones and the green light comes on, this means that "IF" a headphone is plugged in, the volume knob works for the headphone amp. If you don't plug in a headphone and the green light is on, the volume knob works for the DAC output! It was discovered by accident. |