Quote:
Originally Posted by jamato8 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
A good amp or speakers or headphones should do what they are intended to do, amplifier and act as a transducer regardless of what music there is. Sound waves are sound waves and speed of delivery and recovery should not garner support of one type of music or the other in a balanced correctly done system. I have heard this and if something is slanted as to somehow benefit one type of music it generally doesn't sound all that good after a while. Give it to me straight up. If it good with "sound" it is good with anything.
|
I have to disagree with the common feeling about this issue on this thread. While it is true that if a phone is great for a genre it won't be that bad at other it is true that some headphones are more suitable for a certain genre. Unfortunately the perfect headphone doesn't exist. All have trades and depending on the genre, one of these trades can be a showstopper or not.
For example: R10 has a great soundstage that make it great for classical (specially big romantic orchestras), and their great mids/highs make them great for female vocal voices too. A similar thing can be said for the K1000.
The L3000 doesn't have that soundstage and doesn't work as great as those for classical but PRaT and bass is great for most pop and rock and the intimate soundstage and full warm sound make them great for most jazz too.
The bass, impact and slam of PS-1 make them great for hip-hop although L3000 is very good here too. Still, I'm not saying that PS-1 can't do other things but soundstage is not very impressive and classical is not great on them.
The surgical detail of the Qualias make them great for Electronica, especially when you try to follow very complex one with lots of "threads" and "tracks" on the music going on there at the same time. However, they are somehow a bit cold for intimate vocal and acoustic genre (still quite good most of the time though).
I could go on and on for some other headphones but I think you get the idea. Is not that those phones are crap at any style apart from their "ones" (actually they can be very good at them) but it is undeniable that most headphones are especially good in some genres, based on their sonic treats.
Anyway... I was curious about these phones and I ordered a couple of ESW9 headphones from Bluetin last Sunday, among some others. DHL was saying they are already in UK soil so it won't take long for me to try them. I'll let you know how I feel about them. As catscratch was saying, I have been waiting for something quite good on this style of phones and I'll give them a chance. Sometimes I get a bit tired of the UE10s (they are great but a bit intrusive for me) and I use PS-1s or Qualia instead for portable. PS-1 is foldable and works great for hotels. Qualia are nice for walks as they are light and not that bulky, although too microphonic. Besides, I care too much about my phones so I can only use them for portable in "ideal" conditions. I hope ESW9 can help here a bit...