Simulating LCD2s with a K518... Now that's not what I call common sense! If the simulated phones came out on top all the commonsense audiophiles that say you can't polish a turd with EQ would turn into a lynch mob at the door of Olive-Welti! As it stands, for all we know the simulated phones may have gotten lower ratings simply because the subjects knew something was up when they could change the sound of the phones completely at the touch of a button
If just simulating phones could turn in such close results, it's no wonder that I could make cheap phones sound better than expensive ones to me by tweaking the frequency response extensively to fit my preference instead of just blindly following the expensive phones
It would be like the K518 tuned to fit the Olive-Welti target vs the stock LCD2s...