"The Forgotten" - I fell asleep 3 times on that movie. yawn.
As to "Donnie Darko", many are calling it a cult classic.
http://romanticmovies.about.com/libr.../aa102401a.htm
gives it an "A-".
I can't see it - it can easily be explained as a dream sequence. With TT you end up with paradoxes, with a dream sequence there is none; but that may speak to spirituality and as such people may not want to contemplate one's ability for pre-cognition; it is much easier to rationalise that he has super powers.
I see it as just another example of how people cannot come to terms with the fact that there is randomness in the Universe - that there are things that just happen for no discernable and rational reason, that existance is capricious.
I'm sure that there wil be many that will love this movie and see all sorts of "deep" meanings. Since I love Sci-Fi - that's the way I accept it - I don't need to seek deep meaning(s) unless it is of the calibre of "2001".
As for visuals, they are your run of the mill "excellent".
I would rather consider as cult classics, "Final Destination" (
) or "Final Destination 2" (
). FD was the more thrilling of the two; it created more suspense, was more shocking. But, FD2 was more cinematic, more engaging, better acting, more situational, and a buffo surprise ending. I thought FD was bought down by one over the top acting performance - the 'jerk'. That performance was surreal and unbelievable.
Donnie Darko, standing by itself, probably deserves 3 stars. But when compared to Final Destination it is found lacking.