Uncle Erik
Uncle Exotic
- Joined
- Mar 18, 2006
- Posts
- 22,596
- Likes
- 532
Lunatique, some will disagree with me on this, but I don't go after the rare, NOS tubes or high-end new ones. Tubes are a wear item. Therefore, I don't go nuts on something that eventually has to be thrown away. Maybe you can gain a little bit from a special tube, but I find that the circuit is more important than the tubes or individual components.
Even the rarest and most desirable NOS tubes will not make a bad circuit sound good. Neither will the most futzy capacitors and resistors. A good circuit with average tubes will sound better than a bad circuit with the finest parts.
I only buy and build amps that have newly manufactured tubes that are reasonable, or good supplies of NOS tubes that aren't priced into the stratosphere. I can retune my Zana for $50-$60, which is entirely reasonable. I've already put aside stocks of tubes for the next 40-50 years, as well.
The prices were good, so I loaded up. Nothing fancy, but they work and sound fine.
Keep in mind that all parts wear out eventually. If you go to Mouser or Digikey, you'll find the MTBF (mean time before failure) for everything. Even if you're running solid state, the caps and resistors will fail eventually. Failure isn't necessary an explosion of sparks or a fire. Usually, something like a resistor will change from (for example) 100 Ohms to 175 Ohms. The amp will still "work," and the change will happen slowly enough for you not to notice it, but a resistor that does that is out of spec, has failed, and should be replaced. Capacitors do the same thing.
So if you run a solid state amp long enough, you're going to have to replace parts in it. Same with a tube amp. The benefit of tubes is that the circuits are generally simpler than solid state and some of them are built point-to-point. Replacing parts in a point-to-point amp is much simpler than desoldering a PCB, which is easily damaged.
This is why I've gone with tubes, mostly point-to-point, in my gear. I'm more or less done buying equipment and happy with what I have. I intend to maintain it for the rest of my life, then have some very nice vintage stuff to pass on.
Even the rarest and most desirable NOS tubes will not make a bad circuit sound good. Neither will the most futzy capacitors and resistors. A good circuit with average tubes will sound better than a bad circuit with the finest parts.
I only buy and build amps that have newly manufactured tubes that are reasonable, or good supplies of NOS tubes that aren't priced into the stratosphere. I can retune my Zana for $50-$60, which is entirely reasonable. I've already put aside stocks of tubes for the next 40-50 years, as well.
Keep in mind that all parts wear out eventually. If you go to Mouser or Digikey, you'll find the MTBF (mean time before failure) for everything. Even if you're running solid state, the caps and resistors will fail eventually. Failure isn't necessary an explosion of sparks or a fire. Usually, something like a resistor will change from (for example) 100 Ohms to 175 Ohms. The amp will still "work," and the change will happen slowly enough for you not to notice it, but a resistor that does that is out of spec, has failed, and should be replaced. Capacitors do the same thing.
So if you run a solid state amp long enough, you're going to have to replace parts in it. Same with a tube amp. The benefit of tubes is that the circuits are generally simpler than solid state and some of them are built point-to-point. Replacing parts in a point-to-point amp is much simpler than desoldering a PCB, which is easily damaged.
This is why I've gone with tubes, mostly point-to-point, in my gear. I'm more or less done buying equipment and happy with what I have. I intend to maintain it for the rest of my life, then have some very nice vintage stuff to pass on.