linuxworks
Member of the Trade: Sercona Audio
- Joined
- Oct 10, 2008
- Posts
- 3,456
- Likes
- 69
I wonder if other programs have a more automatic router for circuit layout?
I did a test run of eagle (it was my first ever attempt at 'schematic capture' and all the rest that follows up to board layout). I'm 100% self taught (maybe that's the problem, lol) and to be honest, I'm not real impressed with the circuit layout tools in eagle. it 'works' but its not at all easy to get good results from and seems to be more of a manual draw tool with 'connect the lines' thrown in but NOT auto-placement of components.
am I dreaming in that its not realistic to get placement and routing that is pretty usable first-off? or is this in the multi-$K level that I'll never be able to afford? (this is for hobby use only, for me).
in my field (network management) there are tools to do 'auto topology' of discovered IP nodes and even draw the nodes and wires for you. some are very geometry based (which are not very good) and some are 'spring and mass' based which *are* very good. I see the circuit board design problem as very similar to the 'draw a diagram of a subnet' problem. there are good free tools for IP drawing, but are there good ones for circuit layout?
related question: is circuit layout still considered an 'art' in that the person controlling the program matters more than the program? or are things to the point where auto-everything 'just plain works' and you can make due with that more times than not?
I did a test run of eagle (it was my first ever attempt at 'schematic capture' and all the rest that follows up to board layout). I'm 100% self taught (maybe that's the problem, lol) and to be honest, I'm not real impressed with the circuit layout tools in eagle. it 'works' but its not at all easy to get good results from and seems to be more of a manual draw tool with 'connect the lines' thrown in but NOT auto-placement of components.
am I dreaming in that its not realistic to get placement and routing that is pretty usable first-off? or is this in the multi-$K level that I'll never be able to afford? (this is for hobby use only, for me).
in my field (network management) there are tools to do 'auto topology' of discovered IP nodes and even draw the nodes and wires for you. some are very geometry based (which are not very good) and some are 'spring and mass' based which *are* very good. I see the circuit board design problem as very similar to the 'draw a diagram of a subnet' problem. there are good free tools for IP drawing, but are there good ones for circuit layout?
related question: is circuit layout still considered an 'art' in that the person controlling the program matters more than the program? or are things to the point where auto-everything 'just plain works' and you can make due with that more times than not?