The original value determined by mains_hum (one of the 3 designers) was 150 ohms, but you aren't bound by this and can experiment. With higher resistances comes more noise, lower resistance results in less volume control. I would consider the 150 ohms an absolute maximum and work back from there. You may find 75 or 50 ohms is enough.
Most likely, you will find the sound of your SOHA compared to the Creek
different, not better or worse. Again, the original designers used Xicon caps. The point of my post up there was to identify things that you could do to improve sound without spending an arm and a leg. Ultimately, the SOHA sound is mostly dependent on the tube. The first step would be to change the tube. That said, the JJ 12AU7 is one of the recommended tubes that sound good - hence, my post about other things you might try.
If by some small chance you are disatisfied with the sound, those things are the first thing I'd try to change. You could probably get everything I mentioned for less than $20 shipped from Mouser. (Brown Dog adapter for the OPA551's is $3 + $1.85 shipping from
http://www.cimarrontechnology.com) Without the opamps, probably less than $10.
Ultimately, the SOHA should pair very well with a set of Grado's - providing oodles of low-end power and punch, with a mellow smoothing of highs that still provides good detail.
Sounds like you have some stuff to settle with Mouser if they charged you twice for something.