Very true. Still I love a very precise soundstage when I am listening at home. I guess we should say that strive to get a "realistic-ish experience", where a pinpoint imaging has to make up for the lack of visual experience.
I think I have been insufficiently precise. I don’t pretend that one can point exactly to a precise, needle sharp “image” of an individual member of the orchestra. In fact, I find overly “precise”/sharp imaging (as in most dynamic speakers I’ve experienced), to be less convincing for symphonic music well recorded. Far better than Bose ever was or will be, of course. But a realistic soundstage - to me YMMV - can be achieved with planars. There, on the best recordings, I can know very well were instrumentalists “are” (no, not to inches, but angularly and in depth/height location in general 3d space).
Again, Bose’s intent was the complete and utter destruction of a concept of precise (ha!) imaging, or realistic (ha!) soundstage… Todd Rundgren’s “Wall of Sound”, anyone? (That said, in college we’d be known to get a bit baked, and then go visit the local dealer that had them on display for listening and sale. PF Wish you were here - Bose/Baked experience… - ton’s of grins).
So for me, the net is:
1) I love precise imaging on those few recordings that do it very well (anyone ever hear the rotational 3-d angled figure 8 in Kraftwerk’s Tour du France when the bicycle derailleur sound kicks in? Epic if/when you can/do… My Vandersteens were epic at those kinda feats… My stand mount Paradigm Reference 20’s as well; image like a champ…
2) But, to me symphonic orchestra and acoustic jazz sound most “real” on planars… I settled on Apogees, other friends on Maggies, or Martin Logans.
I always tried to get Row 8 - 15 and as close to center as possible for the symphonies I attended; the further back, the less the ability to “generally locate instrumentalists in space”. (Not always, things like Piccolo “pierced through” the distance in fascinating ways even in very big halls!)
So my system, not surprisingly is optimized to try and sound like Row 8ish. This might just be why the introduction of Yggy earlier this month has made such a dramatic improvement on my digital side of the house. I said earlier it made digital sound like music finally (to me). THAT is the characteristic it brought back, the row 8 perspective and soundstage.
So, Planars are great…
But they are harsh mistresses:
1. No particularly cheap
2. Need the right (bigger, and rectangularly symmetrical are both better)
3. Don’t have the deepest/punchiest 20-40Hz region, unless you “amp up” #1 and #2 above… I’m getting a useable 34 Hz in my current (final) room, which is the best ever with them.