Originally Posted by jacal01 /img/forum/go_quote.gif
I have recently discovered the radio stations collection CDs of live band recordings off of their morning drive shows, that they produce annually for charity, foodbanks, etc. Straight pristine reproductions of their favorite songs from the various visiting groups or artists on tour around the country that year.
Just as performed; no congesting, mixing or remastering. Simple, pure and faithful to the performance, and actually imparting a sense of being there. Sweet. With the proper conversion equipment, digital is coming right around...
I lived in the UK back in the day, and I read the hi-fi (what they called it before someone invented "audiophile") magazines. Some highly respected bespectacled boffin opined (and I believed him, based on personal experimentation) that the highest fidelity musical experience available to the house-bound was live FM.
Yes, frequency-modulated over-the-air radio.
The BBC used to send their very best out to broadcast classical music. They would mic up a concert hall, then sit out in their broadcast trucks and send the live results out the world - minimal compression, no processing, just careful mic placement and gain riding. This is the environment that the BBC LS3/5a was spawned in - a speaker design that's about to have its 40th anniversary and is still used as a comparison for modern mini-monitors (read any review of the KEF LS50 speaker, a current well-deserved darling).
I dropped as much as I could on a Magnum-Dynalab tuner and paid some yobbo to put a decent FM ariel on the roof of my rental flat.
Oh. My. God.
Talk about the nearest thing to live music!
But recording it lost the magic, even with dbx on top-notch tape decks. Most of it wasn't actually "recorded" by the BBC, especially with regard to re-broadcast (or re-production) - it was just logged in case someone called in with a language complaint.
I've come close to that experience with some of the NPR broadcasts, but nothing has matched those old BBC live shows. Nobody in the world believes in FM any more, for a start. And as we've complained many times, most recorded music is over-produced and over-compressed.