Pacific Rim (2013): 7/10
Loud, dumb, and unoriginal; but in Guillermo's hands it easily transcends most similar summer fare. For starters, he foregrounds his characters, giving us time to get to know them and like them. The characters here are not lost in the CGI spectacle: they remain a strong focal point throughout, even during the climactic battles. That they are occasionally made to utter really awful lines of dialogue is rendered mostly moot by the actors taking their roles seriously, without tipping over into melodrama. And when tragedy seeps into the picture, it's genuinely affecting stuff. The comic relief, unfortunately, is a bit less successful. Charlie Day, in particular, is given way more screen time than he needs or deserves; I'd rather we'd have seen more of Ron Perlman.
Let's admit it though--the real reason anyone wants to see this is for the robot on giant monster fights. And they are gorgeous. I really do mean gorgeous. Here, with a huge budget and a talented crew, he brings to the screen a wonderfully realized world that trades in the chaotic whiz-bam from schlock like Transformers with generous helpings of detail and creativity. Sure, it may be overly familiar at times, with themes and scenes feeling like they were ripped straight out of Armageddon, Independence Day, Godzilla, and even Neon Genesis Evangelion, but it comes together so well that it's hard to fault it too much, even if it stumbles a bit at the end. And there are other faults, as well: the pacing is a bit off for the first half of the film, the side plot involving the doctors is irritating at best (one or two moments aside), and it's *way* to easy to pick out who the fodder characters are right from the get-go.
Still, this is very much a summer blockbuster worth making time for. If I can make one suggestion: I'd recommend seeing it in 2D, if you can. I have not actually seen the 3D version, but can tell you that this is a very dark film for the most part, with the majority of the action sequences themselves taking place at night or in murky environments (or both!). Unless you know the staff of your local theatre to be quite capable of ensuring that the film's brightness is at the appropriate levels for a 3D screening, then just do yourself a favor and see it in 2D. Save a couple bucks and admire all that extra kaiju and jaeger detail.