Shin Godzilla 8/10
One would be forgiven for thinking they just saw a film that was actually political and social satire with Godzilla as a vehicle. That's the extent of how much the film played the establishment for laughs and self-inflicted conflict.
Even as someone who hasn't seen a good portion of the Godzilla movies, you can just feel the tribute being paid to films of old. From the design of the monster, especially in the beginning (but even to the end), to the film tone and color temperature and the rampage sequences. There were a lot of great "Whoa..." moments with Godzilla, but with a nice helping of cheese.
This was a monster movie that was very very tongue in cheek IMO. And that translated well to an American audience. People got the jokes, of which there were plenty, because they were well delivered and effectively universal, even the ones that weren't politically hinged. Maybe it was an audience who wanted to love this, but the theater was pretty packed and people even applauded at the end.
The end however was a bit anticlimactic and let the film down more than the political maneuvering potentially could. The plan was quintessentially science film, where "science", technology and engineering win out on brute force. And I quote science because the the pace the were going with the science revelations, it may as well have been Jack's beanstalk beans. But as far as action goes at the end, it almost felt "guy in a costume". This was the kind of ending you would expect from a Power Rangers TV movie, not a Godzilla movie. But to be fair, they were pretty much setting up for the next film, almost on the assumption of getting the green light, or that it was a 2 film deal already signed off on.
I was under the impression that this one had two directors, but in a bit of an odd play, if you sat through the credits to the end, there was a bit of subtitling for the localization team, which itself was interesting since it was in Japanese and I'd assume that it wasn't in the Japanese version, and it ended with Written and Directed by Hideaki Anno. No mention of the co-director Shinji Higuchi. I guess Funimation knows their audience?
Anno brought his evA-Game, including composer Shirō Sagisu. When the Decisive Battle arrangement came on, I knew it was "fan service" for the Evangelion faithful, but it worked well for the situation, and truth be told I was giddy as f*. His direction was just a spectacular show of deftly timed cuts and military action sequences.
The Japanese-American politician's daughter Kayoco was an obvious weak point. Not because her speaking English was bad, but because there was no point to it. She just starts speaking English in a room full of full-on native Japanese speaking politicians, when she can obviously speak fluent Japanese. I'm just going to choose to ignore her whole "character" and her fun goal of the US Presidency, but what was on screen wasn't awful. It just didn't add much of anything. What was awful was the quality of the native English speaking actors. They may as well have gotten non-fluent English-speaking Japanese actors to do it. I feel like they walked into an expat bar with a clipboard and a Godzilla Movie Needs You sign.
There's a lead character. I guess you could call him a protagonist. But really, even this appears to be a jab at traditional Japanese culture. He's always there moving and shaking but kind of gets lost in the hustle and bustle of the state of emergency. Really this is more than fine and a welcome change of pace from the classic American disaster movie setup.
I'm actually pretty glad I saw this in theaters. There's something about this kind of movie that needs to be physically larger than life. It was probably actually/closer to being in the mid-high 7's but bonus points for the film having stones to be different and dig through the attic of its own past and the culture that created it.