So I just received my HD8XX today and have some thoughts after a few hours of listening.
Background things to know about me and my preferences:
- My favorite headphones are the DCA Aeon 2 Noire
- Massdrop TH-X00 PH probably 2nd favorite, though I admit I haven't listened to them in awhile
- I've been trying to get more into open backs for music listening now that I no longer need to isolate sounds with new living arrangements
- I've also been trying the HiFiman Ananda and HEDD HEDDphone recently, though don't necessarily love either
- I have HD700 that I love for gaming, but the pads are starting to fall apart
- Finding replacement pads has been a pain so I've been considering an HD8xx-series just for gaming
- I've also considered finding a one-headphone-for-everything
- I was hoping for HD8XX, based on the earlier frequency response graphs, might be that headphone? Low hopes, honestly.
- Realistically, I'm content to have an HD8xx-series for just gaming
- I love scratching the soundstage itch but like the itch-scratch cycle I've never been satisfied by any headphone, including the HD700
- There's always moments of soundstage that hit just right but it never lasts
- I love sub-bass, and specifically sub-bass. I typically leave my Lokius's bottom dial turned up all the way and rarely touch the others. Sometimes I turn down mid-bass or make headphone-specific tweaks.
- The Lokius has been in passthrough mode for a few days in anticipation of this test. I've just been using the HEDDphone the last week-ish.
- EDM is generally my favorite music but have grown to loathe the hallmark sounds of Dubstep. Most of the time I listen to new and unfamiliar music, though I do have multiple playlists of favorites/familiars.
So I connected the HD8XX to my Phonitor XE via 1/4in and put my Lokius to passthrough (no EQ) and fired up my Headphone Testing playlist (lots of songs I like, some songs that highlight things I don't like, all familiar).
And the HD8XX sound like ass. Terrible ass.
And not quite like the newly released EQ charts would indicate.
For starters, there's no mid-bass or sub-bass. The mids are recessed as expected, the bass is even more non-existent, and the highs are all-consuming. The highs aren't unpleasant (no sibilance) just excessively loud.
- The vocals in "Be Like You (ft. Broods)" by Whethan are exhausting and overbearing. There's other screeching instrumentals coming in/out. Everything else feels missing, too. This is a song I like, not a problematic song.
- The bass riff at the ~1min mark in "Killmonger" by Ludwig GΓΆransson is politely wheezing at best. Sounds like a HomePod--something that knows it can't reproduce it and doesn't even try. A lot of the bass detail is completely missing. I can't turn up the volume any higher, the highs are already too much (is this the infamous 6k peak?).
- I double check in "Why So Serious?" by Hans Zimmer, same complete lack of sub-bass. It basically goes quiet at the 3:25 mark.
- "Poison (ft. Sydnee Carter)" by SLUMBERJACK sounds lifeless. I think the EQ charts are accurate based on this song, except still no bass. The soundstage moment late in this song has a head-turning "whoa" moment on first listen. It's gone on the second listen.
- "The Future (Proper Villains Remix) [ft. Jenna Sousa]" by Bassnectar sounds wrong. The bass is missing and the vocals are imbalanced. The build up at 1:15 kind of stumbles in the mids? Wasn't expecting that.
- "Show Me" by SNBRN & Coyote Kisses is also pretty lifeless with occasional splashes of too-much highs. These are simply not EDM headphones.
- "L'Odeur Animale" by Hooverphonic sounds exactly like the recent EQ charts. Like a lot of Hooverphonic, the vocals are prominently featured and the HD8XX is not well suited to this.
- The soundstage in the beginning of "Haunt Me V.2" by Kaskade & The Moth & The Flame is oddly lacking? Didn't expect this.
- "Make You Happy" by Betablock3r feels lifeless, but I can't turn it up any more to try to make more of it.
- I have similar thoughts about a lot of other songs. Timbre isn't even that good at any point, either.
At this point, I'm extremely bummed out by how bad these are. Nothing sounds right.
Time to try these on the Lyr 3 as I don't have an XLR cable to see if it's part of the problem with the Phonitor XE.
- Re-listening to "Make You Happy" by Betablock3r and there's a little bit more life! Timbre is much improved. EQ is still flawed, but these headphones now have positive qualities now!
- Re-listening to the bass riff at the ~1min mark in "Killmonger" by Ludwig GΓΆransson and at least it makes the right sounds now, with all the texture and subtlety. But there's still nowhere near enough of it, even compared to the HEDDphone.
- "ID" by Boombox Cartel & Flosstradamus immediately makes me want to turn down the volume. I don't. As the various layers come in it's clear these are still not great for my preferred music. The drop at 1:05 is just anemic. There's some slam in the mid-bass but no sub-bass. I flip the Lokius on for a second and the HD8XX can do it, so that's good news. Lokius back to passthrough.
- "Hideaway" by Jacob Collier demonstrates the soundstage well. Not sure the soundstage was as good as I was expecting, though. It's not nearly as open/far as I expected or have heard from the HD700.
- "you should see me in a crown" by Billie Eilish sounds pretty good. The recessed mids emphasize her vocal style in an interesting way (where the recession emphasizes her style).
- "Stay for It (ft. Miguel)" by RL Grime is a really interesting song for these as well. The song desperately needs more dynamic range in its mastering, but the way the vocals climb (in volume and pitch) is oddly well matched to the HD8XX and Lyr 3. The instrumental part of the song has more life than other songs.
- Re-listening to "Be Like You (ft. Broods)" by Whethan is still problematic. There's just too much of the vocals and very little of anything else. It's better than on the Phonitor, though.
- The drop in "Chasing Heaven" by Bassnectar & Levitate is extremely congested (by nature). The HD8XX do well but don't crack it/solve it despite lacking the copious amounts of bass that contribute to the congestion.
- Sibilance-prone songs ("LSD" by Ghastly and "Body and Soul (ft. Yael)" by Borgore) don't have sibilance.
So things have definitely improved with the Lyr 3, but still not really impressed. No reason for these to crack my music-listening rotation yet.
Some quick testing with the Lokius enabled on mostly unfamiliar songs (only heard 2-3 times, max) reveals some oddities:
- It never gets the level of sub-bass I want for music listening.
- Trying to fix the recessed mids by turning up the 2k knob gets very shouty very quickly. Confusing. The Lokius's bands might be too wide to fix the 2k hole. Will play with it more later.
I'll let these burn-in overnight on the Lyr 3 and will retest with the Lokius enabled tomorrow, trying to focus more on the technicalities rather than the tuning. But there's a decent chance these are going back, and I've never returned any headphones before. The lack of bass has me rethinking using any HD8xx-series for my gaming headphones, too. I'm not a competitive gamer, I want immersion and a headstage to complement the open-world of the games I play most.
Other factors:
- Love how they look. The blue is extremely subtle, need a lot of light to really notice it.
- Comfort is solid, though the pads are really thin. There's a pretty big air gap naer my temples from the arc of the D-shaped pads going so far forward with no give in the pads. I did buy fenestrated Dekoni pads, but wasn't really planning on using them to try to rescue these.
- Build quality is good, definitely much better than the HD700 and HD6XX I have.